Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> that’s not likely to happen.

Why not? It has happened before.

My Xperia XZ1 Compact:

- runs Android (I'm on Android 10, but might upgrade)

- measures about 14cm diagonally and 8-9mm thick

- uses around 10-15% charge per day of light use (without Google services)

- has a standard headphone jack

- has stereo speakers

- has decent front and back cameras, with no bump

- has a microSD slot

- has a USB type C port

- has a fingerprint sensor (I disabled mine)

- is water-tight and dust-tight (IP68)

- supports VoLTE

- supports WiFi calling

My previous phone was similar, and a bit slimmer. The one before that didn't get such good battery life, but its physical keyboard, swappable battery, and even smaller size made up for having to charge more often.

Obviously, these devices are not common, but they are made from time to time. I'm looking at hardware right now that proves there is no technical barrier. I don't see any reason to dissuade people from asking for a new model.



It’s also a phone that was first announced in 2016, by a company that has lost money for the past 5 years and is basically retreating from the global market.

https://www.androidheadlines.com/2019/05/sony-mobile-strateg...

Not exactly a ringing endorsement of its mobile phone strategy.

And it last a long time not using any services that make Android what it is to most users (ie using Google service) is not a mass market selling point.


You seem to be arguing in bad faith.

Being a few years old does not make my example less valid. (Arguably the opposite, given that it still works well today.) The point is that it meets GP's needs.

Sony's poor marketing strategy was not caused by one phone model, nor is it a requirement for small phones in general.

You could easily adjust the numbers I quoted to estimate battery life with Google services running. Assume half, or a third, if you like. It would still meet GP's needs.


A phone that is a few years old doesn’t have the energy/battery requirements that new phones have because of a more memory hungry operating system that requires a beefier cheapest, more memory hungry cellular chipsets (5G), Google Services, etc.

And if a company can’t sell a phone profitable, it’s not a viable product.

And he admits that he hardly ever uses it.

And that phone will probably not work at all soon in the US if it doesn’t support VoLTE.


And what if none of what you are claiming is true?


Well it’s definitely true for his phone.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: