Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

How many homes could this power for one day?


The energy involved is reasonably modest, on the order of 108J, equivalent to about 30kWh. An average household these days eats a little under 30kWh (which is a lot, by the way, 5 times more than about 3 decades ago). A lightning discharge would supply a home for maybe a day (these days, or maybe 8-15 homes for a day in 1965). With thousands of discharges, that'd neatly be thousands of homes... for a day.


Is this right? According to google, average lightning bolt is 10^8 joules = ~277 kWh, so closer to 9 homes?


Can't be right at all. Photo flash capacitors store hundreds of joules, and if you short them out all you get is a fairly exciting *pow*. Lightning strikes light trees on fire, melt sand, vaporize metal..


I think he meant 10^8 instead of 108.


Oh! Of course.


And that 'megaflash' lasted longer then a usual lightning bolt, I think (was definitely bigger too)


10⁸ J = 27.7̅ kWh


You’re right, and I made a mistake. Looks like the average lightning bolt carries 1 billion joules, so 10^9, not 10^8, which does put it at 277 kWh.


So an average lightning bolt is a gigajoule or so. These aren’t average lightning bolts.

And OP’s comparison point of the energy used by a house in a day seems arbitrary when we are talking about an event that lasts seconds.

If your 30kWh number is reasonable for a house’s daily energy usage, in the 17 second duration of this record breaking lightning bolt a house uses about 21 kJ.

So even if the bolt itself only moves that estimated 1gJ of energy, it’s enough electricity to power about 47000 homes for those 17 seconds.

These are not ‘modest’ amounts of energy by any stretch.


An average US household. In Europe it is more like 10 kWh. Why there is such a large difference I do not know.


There are undoubtedly lots of reasons, but I bet one of them is that air conditioning is much more common and uses a lot of electricity. The US extends much further south than Europe (the states along the US's southern border are at the same latitude as northern Africa) and large sections of the US have hotter summertime temperatures than pretty much anywhere in Europe.


It depends on if the energy consumption figure includes natural gas. It is much more common in the US to use electricity for heating & water heating than it is in europe. Obviously there are other factors but that could explain some of it.


That could explain all of it. Household average here (including 1 person households / apartments etc) is 2479 kwh per year, but also 1169 m3 of natural gas. If you convert that gas to kwh it would be around 10,500 kwh

So 13,000 kwh per year or 35 kwh daily average.


Homes on average are a lot bigger in the US. Plus we tend to use aircon a lot more.


One of the most interesting Feynman lectures is on lightning and electricity in the atmosphere:

> "The current in a lightning stroke is about 10,000 amperes at its peak, and it carries down about 20 coulombs."

https://www.feynmanlectures.caltech.edu/II_09.html




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: