On: Steve's Google Platform rant

[mbyrne]

"Disgruntled" is a straight up ad hominem attack that doesn't address whether or not what the person says is true or not.

[0x12 → mbyrne]

"grouchy, testy, sullen, grumpy, dissatisfied."

All of the above, and I really don't see the ad hominem in there. It's just a description of a state of mind with respect to another entity.

[wanorris → 0x12]

But the real world usage of disgruntled is as a marker for "This person is biased against the company, so any fair-minded person should discount what they have to say."

[mcantor → 0x12]

Ad hominem doesn't mean "calling them a name or label that isn't true"--it means "implying that their argument is less valid because of their state of mind or perspective".