Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

There is no true radio analogue here in the sense of how OP was explaining it.

At least in a wireless context, CDMA and TDMA are flawed examples because, CDMA uses fancy math to split communications over multiple channels and TDMA cuts the channels up into timeslots. You don't get full bandwidth allotment and utilization.

To make a wireless switch, you'd need to have PTP optical/microwave/radio links which have highly directional antennas. This would give you full-bandwidth per user.



Even in a wired context, frame-based protocols inherently utilize TDMA (over multiple channels), just not on timescales you normally think about.

If I'm not mistaken, the radio example uses both frequency division and time division. You're on a particular channel (typically frequency, although AM exists too), and only one person can talk at a given instant, or else you get a collision which results in probably garbled output. (There's also space division at play, since radios are not infinitely powerful.)

If the relay hop is also done over radio, then it's most likely achieved by hopping to dedicated frequencies for backbone comms, ideally with a separate antenna per channel so we can listen on all of them simultaneously. (You could constantly sweep the frequency space, but it's simpler to just have multiple antennas / radios.)

A (modern) real-world example is that I can use my phone as a wifi hotspot. It relays packets to/from its upstream link (4G or even wifi again). (It also presumably behaves like a NAT, but that's an implementation detail.)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: