Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

It's pretty much exclusively states that have implemented either strong zoning laws or strong environmental review processes that have this problem. Can you name a high growth state which doesn't have one of these two problems that is experiencing insane housing prices?



It's mostly the highly urbanized states. You can't just keep building in places like SF or Seattle without also building major infrastructure to support the highly-concentrated population and commerce centers (compared to other less urban states).


The issue in SF and Seattle is absolutely not building major infrastructure, lol. Many areas of SF are 3-4 floors tops. New buildings are height limited by zoning except in the financial district. If anything, Texas has way crappier infrastructure than SF/Seattle.

Zoning and empowering NIMBYs with the ability to block construction is the big differentiator.


It isn’t just the houses, the schools, the sewers, the highways, or the public transit also need upgrades. Even then, a city like Seattle has been building a lot more than SF in the past decade, yet still keeps approaching it in property famous (and yes, we mean land value, not just the structures on them). I live in Ballard. And tons of low density SFHs are being torn down for three story luxury townhomes, and then there are the 5-6 story apartment blocks being built. And this isn’t uncommon in the region. I guess as we approach NYC density, we will approach its property prices as well?


These are very congested cities that need multiple new mass transit lines and freeways (at least) to accommodate the influx of new residents that would come with a massive housing boom. I'm not defending zoning laws or NYMBYism. If anything, many of the same laws restricting new housing are also restricting the ability to build new infrastructure quickly and affordably.


Which is what, every rich urban state? It’s like comparing Nebraska with Colorado, one has more zoning than the other, and is also the more popular state to move to for some reason




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: