Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

A better curriculum would meet you halfway. Write about physics or math, not about ancient classics.

I remember kids in school complaining about math, "we're never going to use this!" Analyzing ancient literature is something you're actually never going to use.




> I remember kids in school complaining about math, "we're never going to use this!"

They probably aren't going to use it, which is why their investments in lottery tickets don't turn out well :-(

I remember hiring a contractor to build an elliptical patio of a certain size. He staked it out, and soon a couple pallets of pavers appeared on the driveway. Something didn't look right. So I measured the major and minor axis of the ellipse, and computed the area. It was 30% smaller than the contracted amount. I then did a little math on the pavers. 30% fewer than was needed.

So I was being overbilled by nearly half.

I asked the contractor about the discrepancy, and he apologized for the "mistake" (ya right) and the bill was adjusted.

I bet the contractor noticed over time that he could shrink the size of the work, and the customer wouldn't notice. So he'd shrink it more for the next customer, and so on, till it got to a whopping 30%.

But if I didn't know high school math, I would never have determined I was being way overbilled.


> I remember kids in school complaining about math, "we're never going to use this!" Analyzing ancient literature is something you're actually never going to use.

Just like any particular math course, you probably won't use your analysis of ancient literature directly. But school isn't training; it's not about learning direct skills, like a training course in a new application at work. It's about learning how to think critically, using may different tools, and about learning about the world.

By analyzing ancient literature, you gain several things: You gain ability in thinking critically about texts - possibly the most essential skill in a post-truth Internet world where we are deluged by texts of varying intentions and truth. You gain skill in writing, by studying how the best authors before you wrote. And not least, you gain exposure to a culture and ideas far outside your own, giving you context and perspective on humanity and on your own culture and ideas.


Yes, and you get to suffer/struggle/strive together with peers, hopefully making friends in the process.


> Analyzing ancient literature is something you're actually never going to use.

Ancient literature, yes, but there are a frightening amount of people who could deal with a reintroduction to ideas like 'unreliable narrators' in the age of social media.


You just gave me an idea because I like ancient history. I'll pretend I'm a freshman and actually write an essay on one of those books. I was never able to do it and failed the class. I've always felt bad about it. Actually writing the essay might be a cathartic experience! I'm retired, I have the time.


Do it right if you’re gonna do it and write it at midnight with an alarm set for 7am the next day.


That's great. Maybe take a class!




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: