OK, I'll play devil's advocate: I think the photo is wonderful.
It got me interested in who he is, got me to click around his website, got me to read some of his articles published in his college newspaper, got me reading his old email newsletters, etc.
Without a photo, I doubt I would have made that first click around.
Personally I think the photo is great, it's nicely personal.
It's more that I don't think it shouldn't be on the home page, it always distracts me where I'd like to focus on the content instead. It would be perfect in the about section I'd say.
When I see a profile pic, especially in the top left, I immediately question whether the author is interested in producing good content or just self-promotion. And yes. The picture you chose is not the most flattering.
This is a harsh comment but there is some truth in it (the photo itself is nice!). I have to admit that I almost disregarded you as someone who is self-promoting. I'm glad I didn't, because this article is good, but bear in mind that other people might do. If it was me I might put a picture on the about page.
I don't know if hotornot.com is the best place to A/B test these things. How many people on that site think you photo is 'hot or not' says nothing about how tacky (or not) it will look in this particular context.
pyre: the A/B testing was more for a profile photo for online dating than for my personal site :) Neither of the photos that I'm using right now on my website was the one that tested the best.