Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

That reverse racism, especially against Asians, is real?



Discrimination against Asians isn't “reverse racism” (to the extent that phrase is ever meaningful), in any sense, unless maybe it's in an environment where Asians historically hold disproportionate social power and have used it to systematically discriminate against non-Asians.


I’m sorry you’re ignorant of history. There used to be laws like “Chinese Exclusion Acts” that were straight up racism based on a theory of racial inferiority of Asians. Now they are being punished for being academically superior in the name of equity, hence the reverse.

Though I agree with you the phrase is mostly meaningless, to the extent it has meaning it’s exactly what I’ve described. Which you seem to agree with, so I’m not sure why you’re flaming me.


> I’m sorry you’re ignorant of history.

I’m...not.

> There used to be laws like “Chinese Exclusion Acts” that were straight up racism based on a theory of racial inferiority of Asians.

Yes, discrimination against Asians is quite common in US history, so any such current discrimination wouldn't be “reverse racism”.


Then what was your point? So, now there is such a thing as reverse racism? I think you just wanted to pick a fight. Be gone. It's reverse racism because they're being punished for their perceived or real superiority as I pointed out. If you can't at least understand that distinction in good faith, you're just arguing for the sake of it.


The parent is trying to say that it’s just regular old racism. Competent Asians are disadvantaged because this serves the elite better.

I think the reason underperforming minorities are so prioritized by the media and the elites is simply that the elites don’t feel much competitive pressure from them, and using them to distract the masses, they can then conveniently screw the minorities that are actually threatening their interests. Another reason is to delegitimize standardization of merit (e.g., standardized comprehensive exams). This allows them to use a subjective (“holistic”) approach that obviously favors themselves.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: