Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

How intelligent can the guy be when he's flagrantly demonstrating such flawed thinking? It calls into question everything he writes, full stop. Better things to do with my time and why give him more audience.



Intelligence has almost nothing to do with it. The whole 'rona thing has been very very stressful and many people have not reacted well to it. Scam artists have exploited this stress (as they always have and always will). Some people have been led astray and some are leading people astray, and some are both.

At any rate, it is an impairment of gathering and processing information correctly, not intelligence. It's a filter problem. I had a really hard time with this too, after seeing how people I previously respected dealt with this whole thing.

---

For what it's worth - I'm strongly in favor of people choosing to get vaccinated and masking up in public. I despise the people who made this a wedge issue for their own benefit.

I also think that being self-righteous about it is very tempting but also very bad and destructive to discourse.


[flagged]


People who disregard everything someone has to say based on one belief are generally pretty stupid themselves. What an impressive way to discourage critical thinking.


> Either way it's a non-negotiable indicator for a high probability of noise in the signal emitting from his general direction.

Well yeah, the noise is the most recent posts.

Easy to filter out, too.

And what, do you not think someone can change in ten years either?


I should judge the accuracy of what someone wrote nearly a decade ago by what I think of what I think they believe today?

It's a popular enough viewpoint today, certainly, but it leads to throwing out huge swaths of perfectly good work that could be useful. Obviously, I reject it. I don't know the guy, I don't know what's happened to him or not in the past decade since he was writing on the deep truths of RV solar. I do know that the more I learn about solar from hands on operation, the more his writings reflected what I'd found through experimentation/analysis/etc. You could apply plenty of his rantings to some of the off-grid battery destroying systems presented on YouTube as Grade A Amazing builds and improve a lot on those systems.

But, if you're only willing to consider the viewpoints of those you would consider show clear thinking, which largely translates to "agrees with what I already think," you're welcome to go through life that way. I tend to find that dreadfully boring and a good way to miss an awful lot of really solid knowledge. I'm happy to learn about lead acid battery quirks from people who've lived with lead acid for half as long as I've been alive, even if I think they make some pretty dumb decisions in life. I know they question some of my decisions back.

Anyway, your mind is clearly settled and the issue is closed on this particular bit of writings. You might go find some of SunKing's rants about "max smoke charging" useful as well, if you're dealing with off grid lead, but I guarantee you won't like him much as a person either.


Greater intelligence & creativity just means you can tell yourself increasingly clever and convincing lies.

Conspiracy-theory-ism is an "emotions" problem, not an "intelligence" problem.


There are many intelligent people who purport to be Christian/Muslim/etc, which all require severely flawed thinking to seriously believe.

What you’re doing is conducting an ad hominem attack, assuming that this dude’s views on one topic have any relevance to the accuracy of a completely different topic (with a nearly decade gap nonetheless).


I take it you discount everything associated with Isaac Newton as well.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: