Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

The thing to look at is when those deaths happened. And when they did they were disproportionate. Once personal protection for health care workers became widespread those severe cases and deaths dropped to much lower levels.



It's still not clear to me that the profession is riskier than just "being an American"? If you have numbers you would like to link to, I'm happy to dig into them.



The 115k worldwide (I was trying to talk about the US, but ok) number comes from the WHO: https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/345300/WHO-...

Their methodology is based on an assumption that healthcare workers are as likely to die of covid as the general population, that is, their job does not expose them to elevated risk. You can see the start of their methodology as:

"As a start, the number of deaths among HCWs was simply estimated by applying the crude mortality rate from each country (namely, the number of deaths reported to the WHO COVID-19 Dashboard divided by the population size) to the estimated number of HCWs in each country derived from ILOSTAT . This simple estimation considers HCWs to have a similar exposure to SARS-CoV-2 infection and risk of death to that of the general population..."

From there they do adjust for some things, but they are the ways that healthcare workers are different, demographically, from the general population. They are not looking at occupational risk.

I could still totally believe that healthcare workers are at elevated occupational risk, but a paper that assumes their risk is what you would expect from their demographics isn't going to help us answer that question.


Ok, I have done some serious searching and nothing came up that substantiates the claim so I'm moving into your camp.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: