Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Well, no one is going to /stop/ you, but somebody is going to think you’re a white supremacist. And I don’t think it would be a rare response.


I've had no shortage of the leftists in my life saying directly "White Supremacy is _everywhere_". They absolutely will take evidence of things like race agnostic capitalization as somehow being evidence of "white supremacy".

Just look at the "open letter" signed by 1,288 "public health professionals" (https://archive.md/v8ehj) which demand an unequal response to the "protests". Demanding strict condemnation of "white protesters resisting stay-home orders" which "are also rooted in white nationalism and run contrary to respect for Black lives."


the "white supremacy" they mean is in the critical sense of the term; not that there are a bunch of Nazis or KKK walking about, but that the institutions of the US favour white people. It's kind of a complex statement that requires background knowledge/understanding, and a lot of leftists who've taken critical studies courses tend to trot out these technical terms while ignoring the fact that most people understand them to mean something completely different.


It is not complex and doesn't require much background knowledge ("critically" reading a couple books like So You Want To Talk About Race is enough, or you can just skip those and read Cynical Theories). This "critical sense of the term" is basically a political wedge. There are two almost completely unrelated issues at play:

1) Institutions, like in most of the world, sort people by class and reward success; therefore, they may propagate class divisions and allow (or even amplify) differences in achievement.

2) Due to the history of the USA, the class in the USA is tied to race to a considerable degree.

(2) can and should be solved separately with policies ranging from affirmative action to reparations/better redistribution; however, this is not what (or not everything that) activists want. Books like New Jim Crow for example are explicitly ambivalent about affirmative action, because it allows some people success while leaving the rest of the poor behind and distracting from the struggle/compassion for them.

Leftists instead bundle those together and use it as a wedge against unsuspecting/apolitical center - if you are against "solving" (1) with leftist policies, you must be a-ok with (2) and therefore you are racist. When in reality, (1) in isolation is one of the greatest things for a society and should not be "solved" at all. Kendi is the most explicit and obvious example of this that comes to mind, others may be less explicit about it.

It's important for Americans to distinguish race from class, and to understand that, just like in the rest of the world, inequality as such is totally fine, and in fact good for society; "equity" is evil beyond school age, as proven thru history every time it has been tried. I grew up ~poor in Russia surrounded by other ~poor people, all white; that made me extremely classist. I personally cannot wait for a wonderful day where every kid has a chance to make a life for themselves, and a representative (M% white, N% black, etc.) upper-middle class in America can look with a slight pity and disdain at similarly (M% white, N% black, etc.) poor and say "you've had your chances, so why cannot you be more like me?" :)


It's good for the hard working to be rewarded, I don't think anyone except the most extreme would disagree with that, including most leftists. The problem in the USA is that black people started out as slaves and this massive social oppression was never balanced out; famously the "thirty acres and a mule" reparations never materialised. As such black people largely remain a separate economic class due explicitly to government policy. The idea of equity as I understand it is to try to emulate or create an actual level playing field, where equality of opportunity is just pretending that race neutral policy creates an even playing field on its own.

The whole "calling people racist for not advocating for equity" thing is ridiculous I agree; I think only a noisy subset of "woke scolds" actually do this. The actual idea is that institutions that ignore the reality of race in America are perpetuating those conditions, and thus are "institutionally racist", but that doesn't mean that the people in that institution are racist; it just means they're not anti-racist, which means they are basically just neutral/ambivalent/unaware.

The postmodern left has a lot of pretty bad behaviour in the public eye, but the underlying theory is sound.


> The problem in the USA is that black people started out as slaves and this massive social oppression was never balanced out

That's not due to lack of opportunity, despite what the race peddlers insist is the only possibility. Plenty of discriminated immigrant groups have surpassed your average White household wealth in a matter of a couple generations.

The problem is largely behavioral, but any discussions of the topic are typically controlled by people that don't let that be an acceptable angle to look at.


OK then, let's look at that. If you're an ambitious person and your entire neighbourhood and everyone you've ever known is poverty-stricken, there are no jobs in your area, and the only thing akin to a route out of poverty is the drug trade, what are you gonna do? Even if you don't want to be involved, gangs may forcibly recruit you at a young age. The problem perpetuates itself as gangs mean no new business will move into the area for fear of being robbed or extorted.

Immigrants moving from other countries are not necessarily stuck in the mindset that comes from poverty and crime. This isn't a uniquely racial thing either; here in the UK we have a near identical problem (minus gun violence) with young poor majority-white men, called chavs. Poverty and lack of opportunity drives crime, and crime tends to perpetuate the same problems that caused it. Thus, the systems-theory aspect of critical theory, which is the complex part I was talking about previously.


You've basically stumbled upon the anti-CRT point that I've been trying to make. Race is not the hinge factor, but demanding that we make it one is a form of racism.


No, that's not the point at all. The point is that explicitly race based policy started a self perpetuating poverty trap, and explicitly anti-racist policy is required to collectively get black people out of it. Because it's self perptuating.

I'd love to know how you think racial equality will be achieved in the US though. Be warned, I am expecting the "personal responsibility" argument and am more than ready to debunk it.


> No, that's not the point at all.

It absolutely is.

> explicitly anti-racist policy is required to collectively get black people out of it.

That's racist. There's White people caught in that same trap. Ignoring them doesn't help anybody, it just codifies racism.

> I'd love to know how you think racial equality will be achieved in the US though.

Personal responsibility is an insufficient summary, but definitely a main thread of what the community needs to do.


There are white people caught in the same trap, yes, and I think they should be helped too. But that's "socialism" in the US. The difference between those cases is that black people were placed into a poverty trap as a result of explicitly racist government policy, and are owed reparations to make amends; yknow, restorative justice and all that.

> Personal responsibility is an insufficient summary, but definitely a main thread of what the community needs to do.

I'd love to know how they're supposed to solve their own poverty, I've no doubt you have a comprehensive plan designed to systematically alleviate such a challenging and destructive social condition.


Just jumping in here, but Native American's also have nearly all of the same issues + more and you don't really see anyone advocating for reparations for them. I encourage you to look up poverty rates, alcoholism and drug use rates, premature deaths, etc. by racial groups from the US Census Bureau. To be clear, I'm not advocating reparations for Natives too, I'm saying poverty and behavior are self-perpetuating cycles that lead to worse outcomes for future generations regardless of race.

Source: am American tribal member


> Native American's also have nearly all of the same issues + more and you don't really see anyone advocating for reparations for them.

You actually do, it's called the "land back" movement. The idea is the same in both cases, which is to say restorative justice. Reparations for black people is to compensate for the non payment of labour under slavery and land back is to compensate for stolen land from native people.

Poverty traps are generally evil, true, and I think that UBI or something like that is a good way to address ahistoric poverty - but poverty rooted in historic actions by the American government should be addressed too, because black and native people today are still suffering from the repercussions of those actions. Germany addressed its actions in ww2 with reparations and concessions, it's a pretty typically American thing to not want to right America's historic wrongs.


Yeah of course, it ends in "pay reparations"!!!11!

Reparations are evil. The welfare state is a big part of what keeps people down.


You know reparations don't have to come in the form of cash payments, right? Like investing in infrastructure, entrepreneur funds, institutional investments etc.

The welfare state is the only thing keeping some people from starving to death. I know you libertarian types are OK with that though, as long as you don't have to watch people die.


Directing government funds by race is racist. An extreme evil abhorrent idea.


I think a big problem is that it's typically not given as an alternative. You're either us or them... which makes sense, otherwise the wedge wouldn't work.

However, I also don't think that to the extent that it is true, this theory correctly identifies the biggest problem. For example, for all the abstract faulting of race-blind institutions in New Jim Crow, most of the actual examples it gives (poll tests, housing segregation, where to enforce the law against drugs/deals, sentencing disparity, etc.) follow the same formula - government power + personal discretion. I.e. good ol' racism that is given the power that can be applied selectively. I think that is a much, much bigger problem than the classist institutions that propagate the resulting racial disparities. If the former issue was resolved by (1) not creating opportunities for it (2) creating compensatory policies like affirmative action/etc.; classist institutions would stop being race-correlated over time.


There's certainly room for that argument - I think the problem is that as it stands right now, the divide is too great to overcome without active intervention because the outcomes of white and black people are bifurcated. Thus, a large effort will need to be undertaken if the races are to reach opportunity parity. I think that the two solutions you posited, reducing the opportunity for active discrimination and providing affirmative action opportunities, are a big help - however some institutional reforms are also necessary, including (in my humble, foreign opinion) government investment in predominantly black schools and enterprises, and ending the drug war which disproportionately affects both the poor, and minorities. Once parity is reached I think these resources could be allocated on a purely economic basis, but until then I think that the US government has a moral obligation to resolve the problems that it created.


Well, those policies do both fall in the same framework. Ending war on drugs is basically removing government power that can be, and is, abused in a racist way. Licensing is another one btw (many occupations require licensing => licenses are not given to felons => drug "crimes" are felonies => boom). Investing in black schools and enterprises is broadly similar to affirmative action in that they are biases that compensate for prior opposite biases. Both are compatible with overall meritocracy and classism...


It's really not true though. Not only do those institutions not prefer White people, but the only cases of people misrepresenting their race are White people pretending to be some other race. That's because it makes it _more_ likely they'll be admitted...


again, it's more complicated than that. Just because institutions are explicitly race-neutral, doesn't mean they actually are. They can easily perpetuate existing problems even if they are legitimately race-agnostic.


I strongly reject the idea that the hinge factor is on race. Whether it's well meaning or ill intentioned, I believe that the continual demand that the focus be on race just creates racism, hate and divide.


well, that certainly is an opinion.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: