Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Semicolons aren't just for high literature: https://serprex.github.io/w/;

> Semicolons are hot

Dash seems a poor substitute. A dash is closer to a period. Semicolons work well for when just using multiple commas would become ambiguous. Shorter sentences also solve that, but sometimes you want a run on sentence, sometimes you want to splice more context in at this very point. & sometimes you just want to drop a conjunction




>> at this very point. & sometimes

Unless you're a famous writer, isn't that against the law?

I thought you're supposed to start a sentence with a capital letter, or can anything follow a hard stop? E.g. is this kosher (?):

Microsoft copied Java. .net, they called it.

Final question; what if your name is kreeben with a lowercase 'k', is this kosher:

Grammar is hard. kreeben does not understand it.

?


That's kosher

Writing has no laws, only rules meant to be broken

English is also a descriptivist language, rather than prescriptivist. ie English has no spec, unlike French (tho you then have French as it is spoken & French as it is specified). As much as Oxford might want to reign it in, they are only cataloging what the collective spews

Examples of miniscule starts: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/of_Montreal where the band's name is always "of Montreal"


> (tho you then have French as it is spoken & French as it is specified)

Which means French has no spec, either, merely people trying to create a specification and failing.


>(tho you then have French as it is spoken & French as it is specified)

You missed an excellent chance to say 'French as she is spoke'

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English_as_She_Is_Spoke


Those are both fine because they're proper names.

Using "&" in place of the word "and" does depart from common usage (though there's no "law") and does so in such an overt way that it appears pretentious.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: