Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Genuinely asking: how? They seem, to me, to be a hype driven thing that doesn't make sense. If I buy an NFT of an art piece, what's stopping others from downloading the same file?


First: I'd like to hear feedback why my previous comment was heavily downvoted. Was it too condescending?

It's not about having access to content, but about owning the "thing". You might buy a painting and post high resolution scans of it: good enough for people to make very convincing copies. But it doesn't affect the ownership of the thing.

NFT is not so much the content, but a record of ownership on the blockchain. And for digital content, that "doesn't make sense" outside of digital realm, it's a very natural tool to produce ability to own something digital.


What does ownership mean though? It’s purely a status at best.


It's even more ridiculous for tweet. It's not even that after spending millions of dollar the buyer got any special right to that tweet. If I would buy a tweet, at minimum I would like an edit access over that tweet and contract that the "real" owner can't delete it.


> I would like an edit access over that tweet

I’d like that on my own tweets, to start.


Not disagreeing with you. Just saying that this is the exact purpose of the NFT - to show that you are the owner of the digital piece, i.e having the receipt/bragging right of it. It has nothing to do with the distribution. Anyone can have a copy.



> to show that you are the owner of the digital piece

Claim of ownership is overrated.

It's just a record on a blockchain.

It is trivial to fork said blockchain, and have a conflicting claim setup on the fork.


It’s trivial to fork a blockchain in the sense that it’s trivial to print factorialboy bucks.

It’s harder to fork the Ethereum blockchain in the same sense that it’s hard to convince people to accept factorial bucks over old fashioned USD.


If you can't tell from my tone, just saying that I am critical of it.


It doesn't have to be something digital... We could move owning real life objects to NFT contracts. Like owning a car would be tracked on the blockchain and there is no paperwork needed about it.


There are applications beyond art. Art NFTs are a toy. Think bigger.

https://www.citydao.io/

FYI I'm not a huge crypto person, I don't know if the above is trustworthy, but it's an example of what you could do. God's knows if it works or collapses in a fire, but it's fun to watch.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: