Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

If PepsiCo (one of the companies listed) ceased production of plastic bottles immediately I would be happy. That is a serious, credible commitment to improve.


They'd still be responsible for killing millions and sickening billions of people via sugar addiction.

I guess human bodies are exempt from being considered part of the natural world.


Is your position really that no one should be allowed to produce products that are unhealthy? This seems incredibly invasive.


no one mentioned banning and the OP is about recognition not enforcement


We don't have to ban them, but we definitely don't have to support and laud them either. Tolerate and shame, like we do with tobacco companies, seems like a reasonable approach.

And to disclose my own biases, I'm 100% on team "Full Sugar Soda" and will definitely choose no soda over sugar free soda every time.


We already do this with a bunch of criteria/ rules for food to be sold to humans and animals.

Lobbying and advertisers have just made us think that drinking a cup of sugar is an acceptable option.


> I guess human bodies are exempt from being considered part of the natural world.

Still this seems to be like moving the goalposts.


In the context of regulating or evaluating company behavior, yes, it would not make sense to consider human bodies as the planetary environment.


Don’t we generally define natural as not human made? Makes sense then that less humans improves the natural world.


Maybe some of us take some resposibility for what we want to eat or drink and dont need government intervention to control it.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: