Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> Maybe historical data alone without other context isn't the best way to predict the future

So how can you get people do unpleasant but necessary work without direct benefit for them?

> much of the open-source world appears to function entirely without "some form of coercion"...

Does it? My impression is that the tedious and unpleasant work in large projects like Linux is often done by those who are paid for it.




>So how can you get people do unpleasant but necessary work without direct benefit for them?

I don't think we're going to be able to discuss this. Our priors are too different. This question sneaks the premise that people won't and don't "do unpleasant but necessary work without direct benefit for them", despite counterexamples littering the (impressively capitalist) world. Engaging with the question on its face is accepting the premise. It'd be like if I asked the parent "by ensuring that nearly everyone has to do often-meaningless and sometimes actively harmful things in order to avoid succumbing to exposure, what are the powerful people (who can, and do, choose not to debase themselves thusly) trying to prevent?"

For that matter, I might recommend David Graeber's Bullshit Jobs, in answer to implication that all work is necessary.

>My impression is that the tedious and unpleasant work in large projects like Linux is often done by those who are paid for it

Linux itself didn't spring from a salaried worker, and large open-source projects having paid maintainers wasn't a requirement for their inception. AFAICT, paid maintainers exist precisely because their open-source projects have grown too large, unwieldy, and important to be allowed to be someone's pet project that's only worked on in spare moments.

And it's not that nobody's interested in large open-source projects, it's that the current system doesn't allow one to focus oneself entirely on something that doesn't make money, because without money, one dies of exposure. I can say this with confidence, because all those open-source projects that now support paid workers evolved from smaller ones whose contributors worked for free-as-in-starving-artist.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: