Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Why not shoot the mortar round at the enemy instead? They travel quite quickly and load/reload very well.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DfkOeHQXAaM

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-tQD5k48QTU

Mortar teams are already indirect fire, and have a variety of methodologies at adjusting aim to pummel the enemy with attacks.

Mortars are devastating weapons, partially because of how quickly you can load and shoot mortars and bombard an area.

-----------

If you want accuracy, you use the missiles I described earlier. Mortars are (relatively) rapid-fire weapons in contrast, with a blast occurring every 3 or so seconds.

----

I'm sure ISIS is trying to come up with new uses for weapons. But... frankly I'm not seeing how strapping a mortar round to a drone is more effective than shooting 20 mortars in the same amount of time.

Or, if precision is needed (urban environment / guerilla situation), TOW missiles. Going to 1940's style joystick controls in a combat situation when the enemy has point-and-shoot TOWs is definitely a disadvantage.

-------

We also have GPS-guided mortar rounds these days btw. No drone needed. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/XM395_Precision_Guided_Mortar_...

Also: laser + GPS guided mortars. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=evqkZAqvOzI




> Why not shoot the mortar round at the enemy instead?

Because all you need is a cheap ass drone and anyone over the age of 10 to pilot it

https://www.defenseone.com/technology/2017/01/drones-isis/13...

https://youtu.be/cz2jrmnm7ds


Why would a drone be cheaper than precision guided mortar fins?

The mortar's arc is so high, that all you need are fins that "guide" the mortar round to its target as it falls back down.

> Because all you need is a cheap ass drone and anyone over the age of 10 to pilot it

You don't even need a pilot for GPS / laser guided mortars. Point the laser at the target, and bam, the mortar round hits the target.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=evqkZAqvOzI

And you can do this like, 15-times per minute with today's mortar systems. How quickly does your drone fly back-and-forth to pick up more mortar rounds?

-----------

Alternatively, you can see the drone as maybe a CAS (Close Air Support)? But generally speaking: CAS airplanes use gatling guns (AC-130 being an exception: it uses a tank-gun from the sky).

Releasing bombs from flying objects isn't very accurate. It seems like the "meta" has increasingly moved towards guns: 105mm tank guns on an AC-130 to accurately shoot tank-shells / high explosives onto a target. Gatling guns from a A10 Warthog, etc. etc. And maybe a guided missile-launch platform here and there.

CAS needs to fly around and fire more than 1 shot to be effective. Dropping one bomb is like, WW2 dive-bomber style combat (fly to target, drop bomb, fly back). If you actually want to sit around and help out the troops for more than one attack, you need multiple payloads, and guns are really good at that.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: