Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> The problem with all these counterpoints is that they take an initial change eg. automobiles and offer a "more" version e.g. air travel.

The same can be said for every one of your examples. Automobiles: horsepower, but more! Like, literally. Last time I saw a car ad, they used the word horsepower. A century later.

> At some point, it's just going to come down to a difference of opinion over which transformation(s) were more qualitative and which were more quantitative. Suffice it to say that I regard all of your counterpoints are quantitive changes, and all of my original points as qualitative.

What makes automobiles qualitative and airplanes quantitative? That sounds very hand wavy.




It is a bit hand wavy. To take the travel example ... it wasn't that long ago that only a tiny percentage of people would ever have considered a journey beyond what could be accomplished on horseback (or even on foot) with all supplies being carried (except perhaps water).

Over time various forms of "mass" transits steadily increased the ease (and thus possibility) of taking longer journeys, but always on a schedule decided by the transport operator.

The development of the automobile (and the infrastructure that it requires) eventually changed this to make it feasible for an automobile owner to undertake almost arbitrary journeys without reference to a transport operator's schedule, and without requiring relatively unusual levels of "explorer-ness" as would have been the case of foot and horse travel.

So there was an inflexion point somewhere at which independent long distance travel switched from being something done only by a tiny percentage of people to something that was quite accessible.

That (for me) is the qualitative change.

Air travel is the quantitative change layered on top of that, which makes the possible distances and destinations of such travel more expansive.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: