Agreed. The article fails to normalize working trucks vs. passenger vehicles as you note. One way to correct for this would be to compare four year-old fuel-inefficient cars to the Prius.
Another aspect ignored by the article is the Domestic vs. Import issue. No matter what Jay Leno says, there is a perception that domestic vehicles fall apart more quickly than imports. You could correct for this by comparing imported fuel-inefficient trucks to the Prius.
All in all, I found that the article pandered to my pre-existing prejudices. When I stepped back and thought about it, the article said nothing more than Green tastes better than Heavy.
I always think of it like this when I get truck hate... You have your prius, me, my ford. The task at hand is to move 2500 pounds of cinder blocks 10 miles down the road to a building site.
Which is now more fuel efficient? F150 or Prius? It all comes down the right vehicle for the job. Thats why its great to have a choice.
I do have such a choice: I own a small, fuel-efficient car and I rented a pickup the last time I needed to move anything like that. I mean, duh, if you are a landscape contractor or a home renovator or you operate a farm, buy a truck. I don't think anyone is arguing with that.
But recognize that you are now the exception to the rule. Do you really think that half or more of the F-150s on the road are "working trucks"?
Another aspect ignored by the article is the Domestic vs. Import issue. No matter what Jay Leno says, there is a perception that domestic vehicles fall apart more quickly than imports. You could correct for this by comparing imported fuel-inefficient trucks to the Prius.
All in all, I found that the article pandered to my pre-existing prejudices. When I stepped back and thought about it, the article said nothing more than Green tastes better than Heavy.