Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Sorry, perhaps I misunderstood what you meant by "infrastructure".

Apple have always had the ability to do great evil to a lot of people, this update doesn't change that. They haven't gained any power they didn't already have.

The government, for example, do not currently have the infrastructure to push updates to iPhone. If they passed laws, built servers etc to allow this then that would be a meaningful change that would be worth all this chatter.




The government, for example, do not currently have the infrastructure to push updates to iPhone

That's the point, this is a slippery slope -- without this system, governments have no way to compel Apple to scan for objectionable photos, Apple could claim, rightly so, that due to encryption technology and privacy, they have no way to do it. But now they've removed both the technological and privacy hurdle, and it's just a matter of logistics.

Now governments know that all they need is a database of banned photos and they can go to Apple and say "In our country, it's illegal to share photos that put our government in a bad light. Here's a database of banned photos. If you don't comply, you can't sell your phones to our 1.4 billion citizens".


I only disagree that Apple could have previously "rightly" said it was impossible.

If China had previously demanded they scan users photos for certain material, then Apple could always have done so.

Sure, it would involve pushing an update to all phones, but so would the change you are talking about (to check more hashes).




Consider applying for YC's W25 batch! Applications are open till Nov 12.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: