Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

They would clearly have been better off putting a diesel generator on a trailer behind the tesla, for fuel efficiency.

4 gal in 20 minutes the video said? That's about a 160kW generator https://www.hardydiesel.com/resources/diesel-generator-fuel-...

I wonder how diesel generator + tesla compares to an actual diesel car.




I've sometimes wondered if it would be viable to build a "range extender" for electric cars which is basically a generator which is designed to integrate with the vehicle, but can be easily removed. Then people could fit them when they were going on longer trips converting the car to a plug-in serial hybrid. Car dealerships could perhaps rent them out and do the install/removal.


Range extenders exist. The 2014 BMW i3 offered one as an option. But now that batteries can provide 200+ miles of range there's less need for them and most EV companies have stopped making them. (Of course this hasn't stopped people from building their own.)

https://www.autobytel.com/car-ownership/technology/what-is-t...


Even for high range cars, this makes so much sense to me. The biggest situation keeping me from getting an electric truck right now is towing something long distance since it kills your range, and often the long distance is way out in the middle of nowhere away from any chargers.

This might be oversimplified, but trains have been giant diesel generators powering electric motors for decades now, so why not add diesel generators to cars?


It does make sense if you need a car with extra-long range. Locomotives are diesel/electric hybrids not specifically because of range but because they need the torque that only electric motors can provide. If it was only about range, trains would just run directly on diesel engines.

Until recently batteries with the energy density needed for trains didn't exist, so the diesel generator was a necessary part of the equation. That is changing however, and battery/electric trains are now being tested.

https://www.bnsf.com/news-media/news-releases/newsrelease.pa...


They gave it such a small fuel tank (2.4 gallons) that it was more than a gimmick than a serious range extender.


Vehicle to vehicle charging is another option. E.g. the new Rivian will support that and several other recently announced cars feature the ability to power external things. Tesla might go there too with e.g. the new cybertruck and other vehicles. And of course using batteries is also a thing for emergency charging services you'd call in if you actually do run out of juice.

The rare driver getting caught completely ignoring their car's warnings that they are running out of power all the way down to zero would have a few options beyond calling in a tow truck. Even just rolling it down a hill would work.


I'm surprised more people don't know that a very similar test has been done [0] (but not towing the generator, which would probably make it lose). Guess today is your lucky day to learn about it and I'm glad to be the one to inform you!

Spoiler: the Tesla+diesel generator wins.

[0] https://reneweconomy.com.au/tesla-ev-charged-with-diesel-gen...


I read somewhere that this was how Chevrolet came up with the Volt concept. They were working on an electric car prototype, and to save charging time at the track, they threw a gas generator in the trunk. They were surprised to find it worked reasonably well. I don't know whether this story is true, though; tonight I couldn't find a source.


Can you charge a tesla through the charging port while driving it?


No. It needs to be in park.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: