Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

It's funny that the author couldn't understand modern Irish farmers well enough to look for this effect. It absolutely does exist in the south-west of the country, and is not limited to farmers. It's not ubiquitous by any means, but it's completely unremarkable to anyone who's spent much time there.

(Maybe I can have a startup that transcribes videos with strong dialects/accents.)




I think the reason they've come to the conclusion it's a farmer thing is related to the included image of "Mikey Joe O'Shea" - a sheep farmer that went semi-viral for having a very thick accent: https://www.irishpost.com/entertainment/irish-farmers-go-vir...

The funny thing is, while the accent is indeed strong that is not IMO what makes what he says difficult to comprehend. He phrases what he says in a way that might be a bit unusual for folks like me (a Scot) so we don't immediately process what he says:

"Well there's 45 sheep missing, like. And the(re's) lambs and everything with the sheep. That's come out to a nice bit of money, like. Be done about it? Nothing"

Really cool accent though. I couldn't make out what his neighbour said immediately after when he points over to a hill in the distance. I think (hope?) that's gaelic because I couldn't make out a single word. He goes on to talk completely clearly in English about how it's a bit better when you have a good dog to protect the sheep.


Ya, it's Irish (aka Irish Gaelic aka Gaeilge). He's just saying the up on the mountain is where the sheep used to be. Not the clearest diction though.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: