Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> Yup. Politicians and governments are, by and large, oblivious to the fact that laws induce behavioral changes.

Come on. Politicians are some of the smartest people in the society. Do you really think they are oblivious or do you think they're just looking out for #1?




> Politicians are some of the smartest people in the society.

[citation needed]

Not that I necessarily disagree, mind you; nor do I want to drag the whole social vs. whatever we call it now intelligence.


I'd say it takes a certain degree of smarts to be able to manipulate people as well as politicians do!


The closest answer would be willful obliviousness. Like how voting for war funding means borrowing the money from sometime in the future. Politicians know these consequences on some level, but willfully just push them out of consideration.

Whatever politicians pushed this in California were counting up the tax revenue that would be collected from Amazon. They couldn't have truly been ignorant that Amazon would pull out, but just kind of put the thought aside to push through the tax plan.

edit: I like btilly's point in the child post too.


You have an excellent point and I think that it is even more cynical than that. They know full well that they wouldn't collect that revenue, but by passing the bill they can pretend that they will, and then they can add that line item to the budget to make it easier to balance on paper (which it has to be before it can be passed).


I'm trying to understand how anyone votes for these people.


Nothing that happens after you're out of office matters.


But are they really looking out for themselves by doing so? A captain that helps sink the ship he's on (and keeps him from drowning) is not "looking out for #1" long-term.


He is if he has a dinghy no one else knows about.


The problem with this is that there is no such dinghy in real life. Immigration is hard (try it sometime), and there's no guarantee that there will be anywhere better to go.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: