Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I think you are misunderstanding her argument and tbh I don't think anyone makes the claim that inflation hurts the poor because they are in debt. If anything it is the exact opposite. Inflation is a benefit to debtors because they get to pay back principal in devalued currency. That's why a cheap 30 year mortgage is an amazing deal in an inflationary environment

Inflation hurts people who don't have access to debt and who are more dependent on cash and on fixed incomes. This is exactly what Lyn claims here:

> There are, however, some groups in lower income brackets that do poorly in inflationary environments. If someone doesn’t have a lot of money and lives on a fixed income in retirement, they have a lot of vulnerability to inflation. Those sorts of folks should consider owning inflation hedges to protect their lifestyle, if they expect that high levels of inflation have a reasonable probability of occurring.




Holy mistype. In GP post I meant to type "good for the poor because they are in debt", which is what Lyn uncritically forwards in OP as a (to be fair common) argument.

"lower classes also have more debt which gets partially inflated away in inflationary environments, and..."

Also the wealthy benefit greatly from debt-based financial instruments (corporate bonds for the companies they run, leveraged trading, forex, options) even if they aren't in debt personally.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: