Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Can you explain more? Because I honestly don't know enough about SANs to know the difference.

To me, a "Storage Area Network" is 1. a cluster of disk-servers, serving the role of exposing logical block-storage over a protocol like iSCSI (whether directly to client machines, or managed and dynamically allocated by hypervisor software like vSphere), where 2. machines are connected to that storage cluster over a dedicated network interface, to keep LAN/WAN packets from contending for throughput with SAN packets.

By that definition, EBS is definitely a SAN. (And technically, so is my two-drive NAS, if I configure it as an iSCSI target and then run a second switch that connects to its second network port and my workstation's second network port.)

Does "SAN" imply some specific internal architecture for the storage cluster or something?

And, if so, then what do you call the type of thing that EBS is?



> Does "SAN" imply some specific internal architecture for the storage cluster or something?

It implies purchasing dedicated hardware. SANs are CAPEX heavy solutions.

> And, if so, then what do you call the type of thing that EBS is?

If you insist, you could call EBS a SAN-as-a-Service, I suppose.


EBS is absolutely SAN-as-a-Service, and it's fantastic.

For a SAN, not only do you have to become a "storage expert", but their individual limitations will leave you with thousands of hours of wasted time and effort, constrain your architecture, and hold back your application's development.

For EBS, you don't need to know anything about storage. You just say "Give me some space and attach it to any VM I want" and you have it. "Expand that space" and you have it. "Give me a snapshot" and you have it. "Give me a bunch of performance guarantees" and you have it. "Make it all encrypted": Done.

You don't need to maintain it, repair it, upgrade it. No maintenance windows to apply a firmware patch. No waiting for someone to buy, deliver, and install a new storage array to get more space. No hoping your hardware has the right interconnects. No upgrading switch backbones to deal with performance issues. And I'm not even a storage person! I'm so happy that I don't deal with SANs anymore.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: