Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Cloudflare Images (cloudflare.com)
65 points by jgrahamc on April 20, 2021 | hide | past | favorite | 17 comments



What’s exciting is the range of options Cloudflare offers for essentially the same thing.

They really are pressing to become the backbone to easy app development. I easily see it and am especially looking forward to the more and more originless options.

I am interested in seeing pricing but another (no offense Cloudflare folks) annoying in-the-dark beta.

To spat off a few ways someone could do similar image stuff, all roughly with them pretty effectively, varying trade-offs of course (origin load, no origin, cost, etc...):

- Current image resize plan ($)

- Custom Origin Resizer + normal CF cache everything

- Custom Origin Resizer + tiered CF cache everything

- Custom Origin Resizer and Mirage/Polish whatever on their +plans

- Custom Origin Resizer + cache everything + ignore query strings via custom cache keys (Enterprise)

- Custom Origin Resizer + cache everything + ignore query strings via worker script to make custom cache keys

- Store the image in an array buffer in their KV store

- Worker + a WASM binding that resizes the image on the fly (they made this as a WebAssembly proof of concept)

- Now this new custom thing.

Very cool.. Love the flexibility and range.


Are they going to let you serve it from your own domain name? I’d love to have my site have a csp default-source self, and not need any other origins listed...


Yes, we plan to support serving images through your own domain though it won't be supported at launch.


I love this, this is a great product for them. Cloudflare has clearly been laying the groundwork for this recently with the Image Resizing feature.

I look forward to seeing what the pricing is, it's disappointing they didn't announce it here. I feel like they've tried to obscure the pricing for Image Resizing, and only made it available to Business customers.

Would love to see Cloudflare be more upfront with the pricing around their image products, and make them available to Free/Pro customers as well.


Cloudflare Images will be priced along two dimensions: # of images stored and # of images delivered. We'll be announcing pricing details in coming weeks!


Pretty cool. Are there any plans for an API to manipulate an image on demand, similar to what imgix.com offers?


Our Image Resizing product offers this already. The Images product (what we announced today) will provide most of the features available with Image Resizing with Variants.



Any benefits over aws cloudfront - > edge lambda -> S3 ?


Reduces egress costs from less steps (where you're paying for bandwidth each time you move bits), no need to manage your own lambda functions, more predictable pricing, API out of the box for variant configuration and image association, easy turn up for existing Cloudflare customers. Would expect it's trivial to CNAME a subdomain of a domain you own to their own white label domain for this service.


We plan to support custom domains (just not at launch!)


You don't generally pay for bandwidth within AWS so those "extra steps" wouldn't factor in to the costs


I admit it has been a while since I've been familiar with specific internal AWS bandwidth costs (cost for transfers between AZs, for example), so my apologies if that was too broad of a stroke (I am familiar with AWS pricing "gotchas" where you incur unexpected costs with services). In any case, Cloudflare does not charge for bandwidth with this product. Cloudfront's egress pricing can be found here [1].

Depending on your use case (from an image hosting & CDN perspective), this product is a slam dunk vs rolling your own on AWS.

[1] https://aws.amazon.com/cloudfront/pricing/


Yeah I'd agree


Any hint at pricing


Cloudflare should not be trusted. They've shown they care more about $ than about doing the right thing.

Once everyone has handed over their DNS and their hosting, do we really believe that Cloudflare isn't going to make exiting them really, really hard?

This is yet another example of how they want to re-centralize the Internet, with them in control of as much of it as possible.


Huh? Did you copy-paste this? This reads like GPT-3...

What a generic and uninsightful comment unrelated to anything with the post.

It is absolutely no secret that Cloudflare is trying to compete more and more as a provider for app development.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: