Hi Dang,
I hope you're well and always appreciate the context you bring to articles like this. Is there a way to turn this into a feature where similar submissions are linked?
Edit: By the way, if anyone has a bright idea about how a community-driven past-thread-references feature should work (which, note btw, includes duplicate detection), I'd be interested to hear them. Emailing hn@ycombinator.com is probably best.
I had a little bit of intimate but impersonal contact with Lawrence Ferlinghetti: the USC special collections library has the notes of his doctoral dissertation, which if I remember correctly was about the theme of the city in poetry/literature. I think he wrote it in Paris, but it was mostly in English. It was on small note cards in pencil and I remember that I had to read it in the presence of the librarian. That was way before I was interested in computers but it's interesting as a contrast. There's a lot of amazing writing online and the ease of putting stuff online makes it possible to see rough thoughts (e.g. tweets), but there's a lot of noise online too and reading lovingly preserved tweets from a fancy library with lots of leather and mahogany might improve the user experience.
"Pity the nation whose people are sheep,
and whose shepherds mislead them.
Pity the nation whose leaders are liars, whose sages are silenced,
and whose bigots haunt the airwaves.
Pity the nation that raises not its voice,
except to praise conquerors and acclaim the bully as hero
and aims to rule the world with force and by torture.
Pity the nation that knows no other language but its own
and no other culture but its own.
Pity the nation whose breath is money
and sleeps the sleep of the too well fed.
Pity the nation — oh, pity the people who allow their rights to erode
and their freedoms to be washed away.
My country, tears of thee, sweet land of liberty.”
From an outsider's perspective, I am saddened by the fact that so many intellectuals decide to balance out generic nationalism of the masses by a mix of pity and resentment towards their own nation.
This is not just American feature, it is the same in all cultures whose language I understand (Czech, Polish, German).
An unfortunate consequence is anti-intellectualism. It is easy to slip into anti-intellectualism if intellectuals cultivate an anti-(American, British, French, German) image.
I wish this did not happen as often as it does now. There is no intrinsic reason for learned people to be antagonistic towards the country/nation they live in. It is a weird fashion.
As a kid who grew up around the Great Lakes and lived for many adult years there, a later in life move out to the West gave me an opportunity to simply drive a couple of hours to San Francisco and explore this amazing city. My first stop was City Lights bookstore, and I was thrilled (and still am) to say I've set foot in the place. Think of it this way - this bookstore predates almost the entire computer industry that most of us here are a part of and take for granted. Amazing.
It is a great bookstore. I live here, and pre-plague used to go maybe every other month or so.
One of the (many) awful casualties of our real estate costs is the infinite bookstore. They just can't afford to stock a book that sells on alternate years.
And no, Amazon doesn't substitute. I don't go to City Lights to buy a book, even though I usually end up also doing that.
Sometimes I feel as if I'm from the last generation that loves bookstores. A lot of them are starting to disappear. I used to spend my Sunday afternoons visiting three different bookstores. Two of the three are long gone.
I've visited most of the famous ones around the world. I rarely visit SF without a stop at City Lights, the place has a soul.
Green Apple’s Inner Sunset location on 9th is also great. Their staff book recommendations are solid. I feel like I usually enjoy their recommendations, even for books I would not buy/read otherwise (bursts the filter bubble).
I admit to occasionally looking at Ferlinghetti's Wikipedia article to see if he was still hanging on, because I knew that with his passing we would be losing one of the last men connected to the whole fascinating world of the Beats. Now there is only Gary Snyder left, long may he live.
They may be a generation removed, but undeniably culturally intwined. I used to have a few beers with Stan on occasion when I was a flailing college student—you could usually find him for a pint at a couple of spots around the Annex in Toronto. He had stories.
edit: I had included "So is David McFadden [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_McFadden_(poet)]" but as soon as I actually looked at the page I'd discovered he's passed as well. I feel fortunate for having the chance to see him read at a small pub across from the AGO a decade ago or so.
Pedantically speaking he isn't, but most would. He was definitely inspired by the beats thematically and stylistically, and has said so in numerous interviews, also touching upon many of the same things as Kerouac, Ginsberg, etc.
> As the Chronicle reports, Ferlinghetti "will be buried in the family plot in the Druid section of the Bolinas Cemetery, beside his late ex-wife, Selby Kirden-Smith."
One thing I've learned just in the past few months is that the “Beat” in Beat Poets wasn’t the musical beat, but beat as in “beat down by life.” Maynard G. Krebs did a lot to distort the reality of what the Beat Poets were about.
Just yesterday, I was listening to a youtube video of Ginsberg doing a read of Howl. It really does seem like a chapter has closed on San Francisco, and its future seems really uncertain and open ended.
You haven't felt the (light) weight of San Francisco history until you've trod upon the creaky steps of City Lights and caught a glimpse of the "Books Not Bombs" sign caught in a dusty sunbeam in a high corner of the store next to a black and white photo of Lawrence in one of his many hats. His influence and reach echoes through the years calling all of us to account and measure up.
As painful, shameful, and beautiful as it is, the baton has been handed to a generation of tech entrepreneurs and their entourages. And as much as I hate to say it, the city will emerge as something completely new and infinitely different.
Is not beauty still beauty /
And truth still truth /
[...] /
Are there not still stars at night /
Can we not still see them /
in the bowl of night /
signaling to us /
some far-out /
beatific destiny?
City Lights is such a special place. A bookstore that really makes you want to read, and somewhere you can find a book you'd never find otherwise. I love that they stayed open late at night too, every time I got dinner in North Beach or Chinatown I'd make a stop at City Lights after and invariably leave with 2-3 books.
His legacy goes far beyond the store, of course, but I'll always be thankful for that place.
Great article overall but I wanted to add in a recommendation for _Her_ -- I've read it many times and still don't know what happens, but there's something about the act of reading it that transports me to a different, more youthful place every time, and not just in the way that reading other books from my youth does. Highly recommend, and very sad to hear this news.
Lawrence Ferlinghetti’s Enduring San Francisco - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19360165 - March 2019 (19 comments)
Salton Sea Notes: Lawrence Ferlinghetti’s California Travel Journals (1961) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10240296 - Sept 2015 (3 comments)
Lawrence Ferlinghetti Recounts More Than Six Decades of Life in San Francisco - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9184856 - March 2015 (5 comments)
There's also these obits from today:
https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/obituaries/lawrence-fer...
https://www.npr.org/2021/02/23/375206219/lawrence-ferlinghet...
(via https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26241243 and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26243128, but no comments there)