Ask HN: What if we had a place to create a Top3 List of anything?

[ThiagoBurgos]

I just joined the world of startups and ideas, and of course I got to know hnews, and since then I have been around the news here and trying to answer questions and help others.

I just launched a new service a more than a month ago, and it was very nice because I could learn from a few users some other features that the service could have.

The idea is simple, a site where you can create a Top3 list about any subject you want and people can agree/disagree, comment, and leave another version of that top3 (and after we provide a consolidated rank on that subject).

I would like suggestions, critics and opinions about the service.

url: http://mytop3.me

[mkr-hn]

Most of the entries seem to be in Portuguese. It might be a good idea to split this off into a different site for each language. Otherwise there's not much reason to have an English interface.

[ThiagoBurgos → mkr-hn]

totally agree! did you create any top3 to see how it works? I will work on that right now.

[mkr-hn → ThiagoBurgos]

It redirects me to the home page any time I try. This is with Firefox 4.0.1.

[ThiagoBurgos → mkr-hn]

did it open a popup for you to login with your facebook credentials?

[mkr-hn → ThiagoBurgos]

I avoid logging in with things like that. That's normally handled with a separate login screen anyway. A blind redirect back to the home page will only frustrate people and make them leave.

[ThiagoBurgos → mkr-hn]

hum ok, I will take this into consideration! thanks for your time and feedback

[ThiagoBurgos]

Also, if any business model pops to your mind, just share here ok?