Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

A question: back when we were all using AltaVista, did we know we needed Google?

Or, put another way, was Catherine Deneuve the next Bridget Bardot?



Because AltaVista was the least awful of the search engines. If you ever found a good site, you had to bookmark it because you knew you'd never find it again with a search engine.

I don't have a good actress comparison, but let's use online maps. I knew that Mapquest was slow and ugly when I was using it, so I jumped ship (fast) to MSN Maps, which was slightly faster and much prettier (still the best looking maps, I'd argue). I didn't have any complaints about it - it was like Google (the search engine) is now. When Google Maps came out, it didn't do everything MSN Maps did but it was so much easier to use for 95% of the time that I quickly jumped ship, again.

If something is going to beat Google, it has to change the game completely, like the the accelerometer did for games (iPhone/Wii) or like Google Maps did for mapping (fast live draggable views). What would that be for search? That's the $100,000,000,000 question.


Funny, Cringely just wrote about the same idea: http://www.pbs.org/cringely/pulpit/2008/pulpit_20080728_0053...


Yes, and Cringely (oddly enough) makes the same point that I was getting at-- when we were using AltaVista, we didn't know we needed something better; it sure seemed good enough at the time.


Weird. I remember thinking of a AltaVista like a cell phone company - necessary evil but not particularly satisfying. I remember routinely looking through 40-50 results before I found what I was looking for and wondering why it couldn't find what I wanted.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: