Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Facebook appears to store the personal data of banned people indefinitely, you can log in a year from now and you'll be greeted with the same message. There is a link to download your account data, but they offer no option to permanently delete it.

Stripping you from your right to exercise control over your personal data is illegal in the EU.




They don’t stop you from exercising control over your personal data. Try sending an email or formal legal request to FB and see if your data is still there in 31 days.


If true, that practice is also illegal in the EU, because requesting account deletion must be as accessible as creating an account.


You can permanently delete your facebook account: https://www.facebook.com/help/224562897555674


You cannot access the link to request permanent deletion once your Facebook account is banned. The web is full of unsolved threads with people trying to find a way to permanently delete a banned Facebook account.


Correct.

I have a Facebook account that was banned three years ago, and I just tried, I can still create a download archive with all of the personal data on it, with no way to access the account deletion capability.

Woops.

Maybe I should inform my country, who just passed GDPR-like legislation, that there is a test case against a company everyone hates.

Win win!


Does that delete the data?


"After 30 days, your account and all your information will be permanently deleted"


And does that delete the data?


The last published DPC audit found that it does [1]. There's not much reason to subject themselves to huge fines and lie about it, a very small fraction of facebook users delete anything.

[1] https://web.archive.org/web/20171218060100/https://www.datap...


If they no longer have your information are you no longer banned? Is data about your ban deleted?


Does it delete the coefficients?


Instagram doesn't seem to. I deleted my account a few years ago, but they still notify me with the updated terms of use. I assume my account is still there, regardless of GDPR.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: