Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Since there is a limited supply of Bitcoin, people are buying Bitcoin now with the hope that there will be more demand for the limited supply in the future. There is a hope that Bitcoin becomes "useful", thus driving demand. Since supply is fixed, demand causes an increase in value.

So, it's a speculative "investment". I suppose whether it's an "investment" depends on your definition of "investment".



It's useful and it has demand for its use. But most people buy it only to make a fortune. This makes it a Ponzi scheme. No contradiction here.


A Ponzi Scheme relies on a central authority, BTC has none. I think you just mean "scheme?"


There is Satoshi's wallet in the root, no need for authority as we can see.


Yes, there is need for a central authority, Charles Ponzi for example. They actively and consciously channel the funds from new, defrauded investors, to that authority.

BTC is not a Ponzi Scheme ; Satoshi is not steering the profits from a pump-and-dump. Passively profiting off new investors buying BTC does not make a Ponzi Scheme.

Market manipulation is not a Ponzi Scheme. A Pyramid Scheme is not a Ponzi Scheme. "Ponzi Scheme" has a real definition.


Agree, I've used it in a more general sense. I mean it's just like a pyramid.


It's not a Pyramid Scheme either, there is no central authority. The benefits of a Pyramid scheme are specifically not investments, but instead explicitly payments for recruiting. Pyramid Scheme also has a real meaning.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: