Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

"Node.js is a way lower-level tool than erlang"

What on Earth are you talking about? Erlang is a language/VM combo (it's hard to separate the two), with nothing else between it and the OS. Node sits on top of a VM not really intended for what it is being used for, so Node has another layer between it and the OS. And the programming style engendered by Node.js is the single most bug-ridden programming style I know, for all its other features. Manually-chopped-up asynchronous callback based programming is a terrible paradigm for code reliability.

Erlang is also unparalleled in general for its error handling. I can't even think of another environment that even has a story equivalent to Erlang's cross-cluster supervision trees built in to the core libraries themselves, let alone one with over a decade of refinement.



I think by "lower-level" he means "having to manage resources by hand that could be handled automatically", not "close to the OS".


Thank you. Put another way, nodejs (except than the VM, granted) has less magic than erlang.

At least it seems that way to me having looked at erlang for no more than a few hours and using nodejs every day, so take this with a grain of salt :)


It wasn't a compliment. :)

Erlang has a scheduler which automatically makes intelligent tuning based on dataflow in ways that are realistically impossible for anybody to do managing callbacks by hand. They aren't "magic", they just take into account a fairly simple cost-per-action model ("reductions") and whether a process is active, has messages to process, or is blocking with an empty mailbox.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: