Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Why is it shady, should Youtube host your video for free? Youtube is an insane free service, there's nothing that comes close to the video and stream quality.

To be honest I'm surprised so many video's have been hosted without ads while the creators cash in outside of Google.



They should give creators an option to pay for hosting or to do revenue share with different ad providers. What a Google does is anti competitive and should be illegal.


> Why is it shady, should Youtube host your video for free?

That has been the service since release, so yes.


It’s still free ...


>should Youtube host your video for free?

Yes, because I am making content for them for free. It is unpaid labor on my part in exchange for free hosting. Now it is unpaid labor that makes them money.


Could someone explain the downvotes? I do not believe this is such a radical opinion. Prior to this change you were still producing content for the YouTube ecosystem for free until you hit 4k view hours. Then you could begin to make a meager amount of money. It is not such a great deal for content creators and now it is even worse.


“I am making content for them for free.”

YouTube is a business.

Hosting and serving your content costs them money.

If your content provides no means to recoup those costs, you’re not doing them a favor, they’re doing you a favor.


You are not making content for youtube _for free_ - because they didn't ask you to do it. You are just making content.

But you did ask youtube to host for free.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: