Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

The underyling concepts are fine, the problem with git for me is the inconsistent command line interface. Stuff I'm doing less often than once a month I have to check in the manual every time. And it's nothing inherently hard - stuff like removing one change from staging or cleaning up local branch to be exactly like remote. The interface just feels like stuff is arbitrarily assigned to different commands :)



> stuff like removing one change from staging

I click on the file and click on "unstage". I don't know why people insist on using the command line for their dvcs. Is it even possible to selectively unstage or reset only a part of a file without a GUI?


> I don't know why people insist on using the command line for their dvcs.

I use both. More complicated stuff I usually do from the command line because I do them rarely enough, and I change IDEs often enough - that I just don't know how to do them in IDEs.

I used git regularly for last 6 years and in that time I've been using eclipse, netbeans, kdevelop, qtcreator, visual studio and intelliJ. And a few fringe IDEs as one-offs. I would have to remember 7 different paths in nested context menus for everything. I believe it's not "unstage" but "rollback" in IntelliJ, but I would have to check that in documentation before I do it anyway.

> Is it even possible to selectively unstage or reset only a part of a file without a GUI?

Sure - it's even faster than in gui, because you do it with keyboard only. I just can't remember the exact options.


You don't have to learn 7 IDEs, I've never used git commands in my IDEs. Just use one git client.

And you don't have to remember the menus because they are contextual. Select a portion of text: unstage selected lines, reset selected lines, etc. Select a commit: checkout, create tag, revert, etc.

Things that are complicated on the CLI become routine and that changes the way you work.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: