Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Virus is too small to be contained by masks that were never meant to be used for this purpose.

They have no virus filter.

Biohazard suit will help you with virus. This masks wont.

masks alone have no significant effect in interrupting the spread of ILI or influenza in the general population, nor in healthcare workers: https://www.cebm.net/covid-19/masking-lack-of-evidence-with-...



masks alone have no significant effect in interrupting the spread of ILI or influenza in the general population, nor in healthcare workers:

Clearly you aren't reading your source well.

Masking lack of evidence with politics

Lack of evidence does not imply evidence to the contrary.

Two were done in healthcare workers and four in family or student clusters.

The problem with these clusters is that there are other ways a virus can infect close contacts. If someone in your dorm, house has the virus, mask alone cannot help because there is shared contact with surfaces. So it does not imply masks do not work.

The face mask trials for influenza-like illness (ILI) reported poor compliance,

Well..

and showed that masks alone have no significant effect in interrupting the spread of ILI or influenza in the general population, nor in healthcare workers.

This is what everyone is saying, masks alone don't help. But masks do help along with other precautions. If you are in a crowd, masks do help if someone standing next to you has the virus. If your coworker or spouse gets infected, masks alone might not help because the risk of surface contact related infection is higher.

It is debatable whether any of these results could be applied to the transmission of SARs-CoV-2.

Different disease with different IR.

However, recent reviews using lower quality evidence found masks to be effective.

This reduces the confidence of your source.

Regardless, even if it's possible masks have a minute reduction on transmission, there is no harm in wearing one. Why not wear it until there are more confident studies which show masks don't help. If that does happen we could even allow doctors to stop wearing masks during surgeries!


Your pants do not protect your from someone else urinating on you but they definitely make it harder for you to do it to someone else, especially by accident. Sorry to be crude.


The problem with this argument is that it relies on people to be altruistic, which I suspect is already negatively correlated with mask wearing.


The virus spreads with water droplets exhaled and coughed by the body. Those droplets are big enough to be contained by the masks.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: