I'd happily take this over mass obnoxious in-your-face spamming any day.

jacobbijani · on July 16, 2008

You know, a lot of users don't even realize its spam. That's kind of the idea. Some of them seem to enjoy it, even.

I'm relieved that the comments on this are mostly against it. I was sort of worried. A captcha is a very delicate balance between not pissing off the good users and keeping the bad users out.

And let's not forget what seems to be the most effective method of cracking a captcha, to just proxy it to an actual user who thinks they are verifying themselves for some other site (porn). This doesn't address that at all.

thwarted · on July 16, 2008

Today I was told, via spam email subject lines, that Elton John died in a rocket crash and James Brown died of a heart attack. Almost fell for it.

Hexstream · on July 16, 2008

And I was told I was "caught naked in the shower". How humiliating it would be if everyone learned I take my shower without clothes!

darjen · on July 16, 2008

Gmail does such a good job at filtering spam that I hardly worry about it anymore.

Hexstream · on July 16, 2008

Email is only one of the many avenues for spam. Try running a search, using Craigslist, reading a popular blog's comment or reading Youtube comments...