Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Section 97.113(a)(4) of the Amateur Service rules prohibits the transmission of “effectively encrypted or encoded messages, including messages that cannot be readily decoded over-the-air for true meaning.”

What _exactly_ that means is, of course, up for debate. Some say you can use encryption as long as the key is publicly available and obvious (i.e. my key is "password"). There's been a bunch of stuff happening in the last year around Winlink. Devil's in the details.



What's the difference between encrypted messages and broadcasting random noise? Who could actually prove otherwise without the key?


Why would you need to prove the difference between noise or encryption?

If they claim is not encrypted it's just noise, prosecute them for broadcasting noise.

If they claim it's not noise it's just encrypted, prosecute them for broadcasting an encrypted signal.

What do you think the practical difference in outcome is?


The practical difference is you can send any sort of data with packet radio, how are they actually going to prove you've hidden an encrypted message inside that without the key (preferably symmetric)?


This isn’t how the law works. It’s like saying ‘why is murder illegal when I can sometimes get away with it.’


Well, broadcasting random noise would be illegal, so...


Every transmission whether data or voice has random noise in it.

We both have a shared key, I send you a cat picture over ham radio with the message encoded in the least significant bit of each pixel.

How exactly is that going to be detected? The picture looks virtually the same as the original.


The point isn’t whether it’s detectable or not.

Not everything is about whether or not you get caught.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: