> Stop what you’re doing right now (i.e. quit reading this blog post), go to your Twitter account, and scan the first screen. Be really dispassionate. How many of the Tweets there could be called ads in the sense I’m using it?
I get 5 that could be considered ads out of 30 tweets; only two of which are actually about things for sale.
It sounds like this guy just isn't very good at picking folks to follow.
0% for me - i use my twitter as a combination tumblelog and async irc, as, it seems, do most of the people i follow (with varying ratios between the two)
Ads are blurbs that are asking for your attention. If they are asking you to go somewhere (link), think about something (statement) or buy something, they are still ads.
Given that twitter is a one-to-many medium, unless your friends (real ones that you hang out with) are directly communicating with you over twitter, its pretty much a given that they are ads.
Assume that you follow P-Diddy. You read his tweets. You have never, nor shall never actually hang out with this person in real life. Every time you read anything he produces, you're consuming his ad. His comments which you receive via twitter are veiled PR/marketing - even if he is providing tangential commentary on events unrelated to himself such as the earthquake in Japan... you are consuming his content.
He is a media icon. Anything he says is designed to drive attention to his brand.
While you may not be purchasing anything he produces with your money -- you are spending your attention on anything you read.
This is the nature of programming (content/media programming, not computer programming) -- You are rewarding media content producers with your attention, eventually that will translate to an expenditure of your money -- which is really a proxy for attention/thought anyway...
EDIT: Given that your handle is 'Technomancy' I would have thought you to understand this much -- unless you dont know the meaning of your own handle...
> Ads are blurbs that are asking for your attention. If they are asking you to go somewhere (link), think about something (statement) or buy something, they are still ads.
Sure, that's why I said only 2 of the 5 ads were things for sale; the others were to things like blog posts. I do realize that I'm in the minority; I only follow about a little over a hundred users. I personally know maybe 70% of them.
I suppose his point stands he is talking about the bigger picture and Twitter in general; I'm just pointing out that if you take some care to curate your followers list it doesn't have to be that way for you.
Honestly, I posted a bit impulsively as the first read of your comment sparked my post, but upon review - you were not as rejecting to the idea as I had originally thought... so, my apologies, though I do stand by my points for others who may not think tweets are ads.
Actually -- then it would make sense for twitter to become a PR extension. They should bolt on a ton or PR services - like managed delivery, metrics, event tie ins etc...
They should work exclusives with celebrities to promote their albums, concerts, movies and events.
There should be special rewards for followers to engage via retweets such as free tickets, lower pricing etc.
There are so many media engagement models that I am just amazed that they aren't doing any of this.
When I interviewed there recently, the only takeaway I had from the experience was organized chaos.
While reading this, I kept thinking that search results are ads too, at least as the author defines them. Google still managed to create a valuable proposition for advertisers, so why couldn't Twitter?
I just got working my Twitter game weekend project: Can you guess who tweeted this? http://who.saidth.at
One thing I haven't realized before I started is how difficult it is to find "quality" tweets. I use celebrities' messages, people who I can reasonably assume that some people would care to know what they have said. But at least half of them just post links and retweets all the time.... Fortunately there are some really good ones as well, so anyways.... :)
I get 5 that could be considered ads out of 30 tweets; only two of which are actually about things for sale.
It sounds like this guy just isn't very good at picking folks to follow.
That said, it's a good thing to be aware of.