Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

It would have been more of a victory if Apple followed through with the action, because repercussions would have hit far and wide.

Fortnite's entrapment move was powerful because Apple's actions are more exemplary than their threats.

Perhaps it's time for some major app makers to have a day or two where they pull their apps.




> Perhaps it's time for some major app makers to have a day or two where they pull their apps.

Epic's actions with Fortnite were effectively this. They were aware Apple would pull the app, but that them doing so would give them clear standing to sue Apple for the contract terms.

For even a lot of "major" app makers though, pulling their apps off iOS in protest would put them out of business. (Even where Android excels in market share, Apple excels in revenue share by a wide margin.) By being a large multiplatform entity with more reliance on consoles and desktops, Epic is one of the few companies that can afford the hit to pick this fight.


If Snapchat, Facebook, Instagram, Whatsapp, PayPal were all pulled for 2 days at the same time, and then put back up, it would make a huge international stink, global headlines to raise awareness.

Literally Joe Biden would hear about it.

Same day take out an editorial or page-sized ad in the Times.

Apple needs apps as much as apps need them, it just takes enough coordination.


Prisoner's Dilemma is in action here. Pulling your app actually costs you money.


If all those apps pulled their versions down at the same time, Facebook/Paypal/Whatapp could very well wind up in court over antitrust concerns as well.


No, Faceboook removing it's app from the appstore does not constitute an issue with anti-trust.


It does if it’s coordinated


I agree that a co-ordinated effort could work, however, to cause Apple the maximum amount of brand/financial damage, it should be timed to the release of the new iPhones.

If Spotify, Youtube and Netflix all pulled their apps a day after the release of the next phone, Apple would be in serious trouble that year. It would effectively permanently devalue their phones and by proxy Apple, because consumers wouldn't be able to trust that that it wouldn't happen again. It would certainly spook investors.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: