Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I come from Montana, and I hate this dichotomy.

The fundamental law of resources in this world is: if you can't farm it, you must mine it. They're a yin and yang. I come from Montana, a state which basically has only two industries: farming and mining. When you live that close to the land, it becomes very apparent who the actual producers are.

Everything else is wanking. Productive wanking, but wanking nonetheless. The welder is nothing without the miner. Without the farmer, he can't even eat. Me, as a software engineer, I'm so far removed from those who are actually producing things that what I do is as ephemeral as the wind. I change states on a magnetic disk all day. I lift weights, run, and have a stand-up desk so my body doesn't decay while I do this ludicrously minimal amount of work each day, but because I know how to shape those bits in a certain way, society values me much more than the guy who feeds me, or the guy who mines the rare earths that make my job possible.




Miners use software to find minerals to mine, farmers use Combines and harvesters run with software. The farmers plant seeds and use fertilizers and pesticides that were created with the help of software. Mining and farming equipment is designed and built using software. If a farmer or miner gets sick, a doctor might use software to display and interpret their MRI or ultrasound.

We have come a long way from subsistance farming, and computers, software, and the people who create them have helped make miners and farmers (and everyone else's) lives much easier and better than they would be if people only mined and farmed.

So, congratulations for doing important work!


Tourism is very big in Montana too.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: