Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
The bare necessities (economist.com)
13 points by terpua on July 8, 2008 | hide | past | favorite | 6 comments



Anybody know what the deal is with Japan?

I've heard that basic necessities are expensive there, but I'm having trouble getting my brain around the idea that Japan is the only developed nation in the world that doesn't fall into the >25% category.


I had the exact same question when I went to Japan.

Apparently, the way the Japanese government works, the rural districts are overly represented in the Diet, with each rural district having the same clout as an urban district, like the U.S. Senate. In other words, for political parties, it is much more favorable to court the rural vote than the urban one. Thus, almost all political parties want the support of the farmers and so promise lots of subsidies and protection from foreign competition. The farmer's associations perpetuate this cycle, because they drop support for political parties if they are not getting their demands.

This results in some ridiculous prices for food staples. When I was in Japan three years ago, I remember that the cheapest 5kg bag of rice was about $20. The only plant that I could afford to eat regularly was cabbage, because fruits like peaches and plums were about $10 each and were usually given as gifts instead of regularly eaten as snacks or dessert.


It never seemed like a hard up place when I visited. Expensive yet, but people seem to be pretty comfortable (perhaps I didn't see a chunk of society that struggle to eat, but I doubt it).


Countries which are surprisingly green: Venezuela (some kind of crazy government subsidy scheme, perhaps?) and Thailand.

Countries which are surprisingly yellow: Japan, as mentioned earlier.

Countries which are surprisingly orange: Argentina. I don't know much about it, but I was under the impression it was relatively prosperous by South American standards, and had lots of agriculture.

No big surprises in the red ones, for me.


Does fuel include transportation? I assume it includes utilities, and repair of heating devices.

Because with those assumptions I'm spending more like 60% of my income on those things, in the US. Perhaps I'm not buying enough of the other stuff.


It's really nice to know that I could tighten my belt so much more.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: