Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

[flagged]


You're finding racial issues where there are none. The master-slave terminology used in technology comes from the human activity hence the sensitivity around usage. The terms blackbox and whitebox never had anything to do with human usage or racial meaning. Let's not create history that doesn't exist and go overboard. They are just colors.


I do find a racial bias in the photos used to showcase the work though: not a single black person in there, not even in the famous ones.


>I do find a racial bias in the photos used to showcase the work though

I'm as liberal as they come but — is this the kind of thing we're going to be doing now? Really?

Anyways, you didn't look hard enough. The forth person on the page is African American (the first three appear to be: one Asian person and two Indigenous persons).


> "The conclusion here, broadly, is that white-box is better than black-box for this application."

Well I think this is incorrect. Generally speaking, a black-box exposes an interface that you can use, and a white-box is something you can internally modify.

One is not necessarily better than the other. Using a white-box approach can create tight-coupling between components in a system as you could be relying on internal mechanisms, whereas a black-box approach enforces boundaries in your system which is generally good. Also, it's often better to test systems with a black-box mentality to ensure security, resilience etc...

It's not inherently representing good/bad, however modern terms like, opaque/transparent might be more accurate and less controversial I suppose.


...

Between day and night, between black and white

There is more, there is more than gray

Between the question and the answer

There's the silence of the sea

Between the cradle and the grave

There is the someone that is me

Between yesterday and tomorrow

There is more, there is more than a day

...

— https://www.streetdirectory.com/lyricadvisor/song/ceeoup/bet...


I'm curious how this is racial? Light is white, a lack of light is black.


[flagged]


To avoid accusations of racism, use "double-plus-un-white" instead of "black"


The 'box' is generally considered to be a system that completes a process on input to generate output. White and black are references to the state of illumination of the inner workings of the machine.

White box is not better, it just defeats the mystery/freedom of the abstraction.

That said, given that we describe races as white and black, I'm happy to eventually pick up a new convention if it makes folks uncomfortable. I say eventually because the current trend is to consider most of these shallow accommodations as 'performative', and I have no interest in being involved in any action that could be construed as being done for social credit where there is little or no actual value. If i felt or had evidence that it actually did help it would be a different story.


I would probably use transparent and opaque.


I was about to suggest “open box” and “sealed box”.

The terms “black box” and “white box” just don’t do a very good job of illuminating the concepts they represent to people new to the field — white doesn’t mean transparent.


> seem to be standard terms from the ML literature

No, those terms greatly predate any kind of ML.

Another term is crystal box.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: