Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

"But we all know, being inside of a brain and thinking as we read this, that something other than behavior is involved with consciousness

You shouldn't say "we all know". I definitely don't know that.



So there is no ego inside your head, no awareness of yourself? Am I talking to a spam bot or something?

But you're right, I should have said "I know" since I can't know what's in your head.


I think that 'ego' and 'awareness' are abstractions we have invented in order to communicate about how we experience our perceptions, memories, and actions subjectively. However all of these perceptions, memories, emotions, and actions are, fundamentally, behaviours implemented by neurons, as is the 'subjective' self-aware experiencing that we do. It is all 'behaviour'.


Your words give lie to that - in order to "experience our perceptions" there has to be a 'me' in there. You know what I'm talking about - the guy in your head that you are aware of at all times.

Behavior is observed from the outside. But what about that 'feeling' you get inside your own head, that you are really there? The act of observing it means you are something else than the behavior.


Not really. In a programming language, for example, there is a feature called 'introspection' where the program can examine an object in memory as it runs and determine its type. It doesn't mean the program is self aware. I can think about how I experienced something - but it's just a neural computation 'about' another neural computation. No magic.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2027 batch! Applications are open till November 2.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: