Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Should contracts be enforceable?

Should we live in a world where people can take other people’s property with no recourse?




There are laws and risks associated with renting, and you will often find that the landlord is the one breaking the law or contract.


>Should contracts be enforceable?

Sometimes yes, other times no they should be void or unenforceable. Quick example: an employee non-compete clause in California (which are illegal in California but employers include them regularly)

>Should we live in a world where people can take other people’s property with no recourse?

Like the colonist (and later Americans) took the property and land of native Americans?

Or like squatting where one party acquires legal title to property from the own after x years? This is generally legal.

Or like eminent domain where rich people get the local government to take private property on their behalf?

One of the great ironies the great capitalist Trump has quite the history of supporting The taking of lands /property to be given to developers, and the scary socialist Bernie sanders has fought against these acts to uphold Private property rights.


In too many small communities, the only people interested in day to day governing are the ones bending it to their financial interest. Usually property developers, sometimes people who own a local industry or visible store front (auto dealers). American's seem to be waking up.


I like your optimism and I hope true change happens For the better, I’m more than a little jaded and in my experience things only get worse.

Take “Poletown” where GM got the government to seize 1,500 homes, 144 businesses and 16 churches and bulldoze them to the ground to build a GM plant.

Ultimately GM provided half the number of promised jobs and ultimately closed the plant.

I fear what we are seeing now is 20-40M Americans lost their jobs, nearly that many will become homeless in the near future, and ultimately they will be swept under the rug (just removed from employment numbers And every other program like they don’t even exist). Watch unemployment Numbers go back to 5% or so and the politicians go back to bragging about the economy. Once you have 40M+ homeless there is no possibility for them to organize and have a voice...they won’t even have the literal energy to survive let alone effect change, they will be steamrolled just like poletown was and no one will ever even know not unlike poletown.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: