the solution is the people who wish to temporarily detain people should create systems that do so humanely...i.e.,
* without intentionally separating families as punishment
* without freezing/starving/killing/forgetting people
* without detaining the wrong people because of their skin color
The fact that people want/feel a need to do this does not create a requirement for them to allow anyone to do in in as slapshod a way as possible. The problem you state was created by ICE's behavior, not by California's concern for that behavior.
> People presenting themselves as families doesn't actual mean they are families.
While that does happen, it's not as common as people think it is. A common statistic cited (and you might be alluding to) that ICE has released is that 30% of asylum seekers are faking family relationships. But that's blatantly false. This statistic comes from a pilot program of running DNA tests on migrants that ICE conducted. What they leave out is it was a pilot program for suspected human traffickers. So it's not 30% of migrants that are human traffickers, it's 30% of suspected human traffickers are actually human traffickers.
they use the threat of separation as a tool...when they stop doing that people can start straw manning in their defense. Until then, it doesn't sound like people lying to them is what they care about.
* without intentionally separating families as punishment
* without freezing/starving/killing/forgetting people
* without detaining the wrong people because of their skin color
The fact that people want/feel a need to do this does not create a requirement for them to allow anyone to do in in as slapshod a way as possible. The problem you state was created by ICE's behavior, not by California's concern for that behavior.