Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

But measles wasn't a pandemic! Everyone keeps thinking this is about individual risk and trying to downplay things, and it's not like that.

Our grandparents went to measles parties because they knew that they'd eventually be exposed and wanted to do it under controlled conditions where they knew treatment was available and had a plan for early detection of symptoms.

The situation with COVID-19 is that people who get sick are going to do so in an environment where they and their government are surprised as "how fast it grew" and where all the hospital beds (and oxygen masks, and ventilators, and intubation kits, and doctors, and nurses, and...) are going to be filled by other sick people.

And a lot of them are going to die, who didn't need to if we had just taken this seriously and not told people "it's just like measles".




My reading of melling was to actually infect young and healthy people under controlled circumstances such that herd immunity builds.

To that teambayleaf pointed out that it comes at high individual risk.

But in the past this was done for measles at similar risk.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: