Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>Uh, regular blood pressure monitors are not heavy and are quite portable. They're just not wrist form-factor.

That's the whole point. The parent's point wasn't that you need a U-HAUL to carry them, but that they're a bulky added device you have to carry and operate specially.

>I'm not sure what's compelling about having one strapped to your wrist.

Isn't it obvious? That you always have it with you, it can take automatic measurements periodically without a fuss, it's on a device that also does 5-10 other things (time, notifications, heart rate, step-meter, etc), and you can just forget about it.



> The parent's point wasn't that you need a U-HAUL to carry them, but that they're a bulky added device you have to carry and operate specially.

That's a very charitable reading of GP's statement. I mean, here's what GP said:

> This is a huge improvement against regular blood presure monitors (which are heavy, and nonportable).

Regular BP monitors are not heavy or nonportable in any objective sense; and claiming this product is a "huge improvement" implies existing monitors are relatively "hugely" more heavy or hugely more nonportable. That isn't true as a point of comparison, and what was I remarking on.


Withings new monitors are pretty small, obviously bigger than this watch but also super accurate https://www.withings.com/us/en/bpm-connect


What's the point of automatically taking wildly inaccurate measurements?


Who said that?

They say:

"HeartGuide is the first, ___clinically accurate___, wearable blood pressure monitor."


There's no way wrist BPs, taken automatically, will have any useful degree of accuracy. They're pretty useless under ideal conditions as it is.


Like "clinically proven," the term you emphasized is unregulated and means nothing to a consumer.


Well, we'll wait for the reviews.

The Apple Watch ECG has been shown to be very accurate.


No one expected otherwise. The things it's measuring are fairly easy to measure from the wrist (if you're able to account for noise).




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: