Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Seems the article has confused cause and effect. US health care costs haven't caused poor health. Poor health has caused US health care costs.

40% of American adults are obese. Obesity causes heart disease, stroke, diabetes, and cancer. Diseases raise a person's health care costs. Costs do not make that person obese.

It's also not a head tax, because healthy people don't pay it. Obese people need to accept personal responsibility for their condition and stop trying to leech off the system.



It's very rare to hear someone say "I won't eat this burrito - I won't be able to afford the diabetes treatment in 50 years".


It's much worse than this.

Dr: "Stop eating burritos and soda or you will need insulin"

Average Joe: "Ok just give me insulin."

Type 2 is largely reversible by diet and exercise. But people would rather just eat burritos and be sick.


Do burritos increase your risk of contracting diabetes?


The article does not say that health care costs cause poor health. It says that we have poor health in spite of our high health care costs.

Also, you stated that poor health is the cause of high US health care costs and that's not true, either. It's one of the many conctributors.

Also also, healthy people do pay it if they have health insurance and/or pay taxes that contribute to Medicare/Medicaid.

I agree that obesity is a problem though. I also believe that many of these articles about the American healthcare system falsely attribute poorer health to our healthcare system rather than at least partially attributing it to unhealthy lifestyles.


> The article does not say that health care costs cause poor health. It says that we have poor health in spite of our high health care costs.

I think the way it's presented in the article ("health outcomes") strongly implies that healthcare quality in the US is not as good as other countries with lower costs.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: