Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

If you ask most (Han) Chinese, the thing they prize the most is stability.

Nearly every change in political system, or power struggle, has resulted in the deaths of tens of millions of Chinese for the past two centuries. The current post-Deng CPC model, for all its faults, does have peaceful transitions of power.

It remains to be seen whether or not today's wealthier China would also consider economic stability to be just as important.



> peaceful transitions of power

Didn't Xi Jinping declare himself president for life?


Yes, but he declared it peacefully.


What about jailing previous president and launching campaign against his supporters in name of anti corruption.


Hu Jintao was never jailed and the anti-corruption campaign wasn't so much targeting his supporters, but instead people Hu couldn't afford to get rid of, such as former security minister Zhou Yongkang. No one received worse punishment than a prison sentence, so even if you count the anti-corruption campaign as part of the power transition, it was still a peaceful one.


> Nearly every change in political system, or power struggle, has resulted in the deaths of tens of millions of Chinese for the past two centuries. The current post-Deng CPC model, for all its faults, does have peaceful transitions of power.

Regime changes have been almost always bloody. That is true everywhere in the world. Chinese has over 2000 years of history to prove that point.


The assumption being that most Chinese feel absolutely free to disparage their government...?


In private? Absolutely. Lately I've heard a lot of critical remarks about 全面小康, the promise that moderate prosperity would be achieved for everyone by 2020. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moderately_prosperous_society


> In private? Absolutely.

That doesn't sound like "absolutely free". Maybe I'm missing he sarcasm.


That statement is ironically correct under most context of Chinese culture. The definition of “freedom” for common Chinese is just like that and few points a finger


The context was:

> If you ask most (Han) Chinese, the thing they prize the most is stability.

If you ask your questions in a private setting, you'll likely get honest answers.


[flagged]


It depends on the context of where you're expressing dissent.

Just to family or friends? Nothing's gonna happen.

Evangelizing it over and over in a giant public wechat group? Mmm.... maybe not as safe.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: