Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

You think that, after a company has had a worker doing good work for them for years, they should fire the worker and replace them with an unknown, possibly of lower quality? Why? Who does this benefit?


The citizen of the country in which is job is located... or at least currently located.


How does it help me as a natural-born US citizen to fire my competent, experienced immigrant coworkers and replace them with some noobs who memorized FizzBuzz?

I mean maybe it puts me in a better negotiating position if you artificially cap supply, but if my team fails to ship a product and meet our OKRs, that seems like a much bigger effect on my salary.


I worked for a company that hired heavily through the H1b. The ceo was a good guy who worked in good faith but he was replaced with a bit of an asshole who moved the office from The north bay to the South Bay, changed to an open office, and banned telecommuting (“because this is what google does”, though evidently the free meals, gym, and other things google does had less appeal to him).

Most of the us citizens quit, but the h1b holders, many of whom were still in the green card queue, stuck it out. I absolutely do not fault them for this. It was during the 2008 banking crisis and losing a job could be a severe setback from an immigration perspective in that market.

However it did mean that the company got away with bullying their workforce in a way that would not fly if workers were free members of the society they live in, rather than people who are allowed here only if they remain in the good graces of their employer.

I could go on about why this isn’t good for the tech workforce in general, but I hope it’s pretty clear. I hope it’s also clear that you can support immigration without thinking this is a good arrangement for workers. In fact I’m bewildered that people think it’s pro immigrant to put corporations in control of the system like this


Yes, I agree wholeheartedly - the H-1B tied hands system is bad (and your story is a perfect example of how it acts as a massive government interference in free markets and what precisely goes wrong).

The application process being discussed here is about green cards, which remove those handcuffs from the workers. Those companies which do sponsor green cards are basically giving up their ability to pressure workers in these ways.

Still, it seems clear to me that the employees are happier staying (and having joined knowing this risk) than going back to their original country, even despite the downsides. I'd say the underlying problem here isn't "Hire American" but "Don't create a class of workers that are stuck at their employer's company." American workers are better off when their H-1B coworkers can credibly threaten to quit.


The thing is, the green card sponsorship can take a long time and become another non market mechanism to coerce an otherwise in demand worker to remain with an employer. You can transfer from one “sponsor” to another, but if your new employer goes under and you lied your job (or if you get fired), the entire time you waited us now at risk.

To me, it’s s sign off a profoundly broken process that we’re even taking about “sponsors” like this.

Lastly even if you awarded the green card immediately to the worker, it still gives a corporation the right to deny it grant us residency rights to an applicant which will profoundly affect negotiations and so much else. For example once I got into it with an interviewer who was clearly trying to get to say “always write tests first” and it was irritating me so we went at it. No hire.

Totally fair but should this jackass bee Ed choosing who gets to have a green card based on their acquiescence to his views on software development in an interview?


You are missing the point. H1-B’s depress wages because of the handcuffs.

Nobody is arguing not to allow “foreigners”, the argument is, if they are as skilled as you claim, they ought to be brought in an open market system and their salaries should commesurate.

The government seems smarter than you and realizes that H1-B’s are not a method to bring talent into the US, but a means to bring in cheaper talent into the US and we see that reflected in their salaries, If they were the LeBron James of software Engineering, you would see that show up, e.g. Larry Page and Sergey Brin.

But you seem more interested in arguing some Libertarian pipe dream that doesn't exist. There isn't a free market for labor snd their never will be because that would cause salaries to rise.


If an “open market system” means that immigrants should be hired on an equal footing with citizens without being tied to a single employer who holds undue power over them, then I agree with you. You seem to be arguing the exact opposite (for more protectionism) though.

The H-1B is essentially the only way to bring skilled workers into the US, besides a few other small niche categories. Almost ALL foreign skilled workers, not just the cheap ones, come in on that visa category. You have many fundamental factual misunderstandings about the reality of the program but that doesn’t seem to stop you from forming very strong opinions about it.

I know many H-1Bs who make >1m/year, so it’s categorically not just for cheap talent.


The median salary of an H1-B is $80,000.

How is this even a debate as to the purpose of an H1-B? It is literally to increase supply of talent for the purpose of reducing labor cost.


If immigrants depress wages then why is the Bay Area the best paying tech city in the entire world by a very large margin? There are a lot of immigrants there, are there not?

You would expect an isolationist dictatorship like North Korea to have the best wages.

The H-1B program represents almost the entirety of the American skilled immigration program. To ask what the H1-B program is for is to ask what skilled immigration is for. And skilled immigration is necessary for any company to become world beaters. Why do all the top European soccer teams have so many foreign players? Do you think it’s because they are too cheap to hire locals? You can’t conquer the world the way the valley has by tapping only 5% of the talent pool.

Of course the program has many flaws (such as restricting the ability for immigrants to change jobs), but more protectionism and bigotry is not the answer to these flaws.


> If immigrants depress wages then why is the Bay Area the best paying tech city in the entire world by a very large margin?

Because of the factors that make it favorable to high-tech industry.

> There are a lot of immigrants there, are there not?

Yes, many of them brought in specifically to mitigate upward wage pressure.

> You would expect an isolationist dictatorship like North Korea to have the best wages.

No, you wouldn't; you are confusing a ceteris paribus effect with a sole driver effect.


> Because of the factors that make it favorable to high-tech industry.

The main factor is the extremely high concentration of the best tech talent in the world, many of whom are immigrants. What else do you think is special about Mountain View and Menlo Park? The strip malls and shitty public transit?


No, because it makes the output of this job less competitive. If you only consider the citizen directly involved in creating that output - maybe.

But if that persons needs anything else created by other people in similar conditions (hired based on blood, not merits), that citizen also gets a bad deal: they paid more for something of a lesser quality.

But hey, warm fuzzy feelings.


Warm fuzzy feelings, and scientific results, both point to in-group preference being advantageous for members of the group [1,2,3].

I'm sure now that you're aware of these results, you'll update your beliefs accordingly - either that in-group favoritism is advantageous, or at the very least that we can't yet be sure getting rid of it is.

[1] The Evolutionary Dominance of Ethnocentric Cooperation: http://jasss.soc.surrey.ac.uk/16/3/7.html

[2] Evolution of in-group favoritism: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3380441/

[3] The Evolution of Ethnocentrism: http://www-personal.umich.edu/~axe/research/Hammond%20and%20... (journal version: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0022002706293470) - key quote: "When cooperation is especially costly to individuals, the authors show how ethnocentrism itself can be necessary to sustain cooperation."


In-group favoritism is certainly advantageous, but software engineering is hard. Being able to see a team of fellow $race at nearby desks isn't nearly as valuable to me as them successfully writing software that works. Those studies discuss agents solving games like the Prisoner's Dilemma, where all the agents are equally capable of participating, winning, and losing. I want to see a study where different agents have different skill levels, and the various groups aren't divided on skill lines. My instinct is that the strategy of "work with high-skilled agents from wherever" will beat the strategy of "work with my group".


Are South American migrants more talented than local migrants? Are American Migrants more talented than South American?

I don't think so they, benefit from the efficiencies of being in the United States. The issue is cost of labor. Always is, always will be.

Corporations are not moving jobs offshore because there is more talent there, it is because the cost is cheaper.


If you want to hire the most talented software engineers on the market, why would you expect them to be all in the US, or all in South America?

Also, neither H-1Bs nor green cards are about moving jobs offshore, they are about moving people onshore.


What if I’m a coastal techie and my preferred in-group is people who share my cosmopolitan globalist values? Since in-group favoritism is proven to be a good thing should I discriminate against and refuse to hire nativists like you? After all that’s what the science says right?


Then other groups will exploit you for unreciprocated cooperation, as described in the articles I linked. You won't be able to differentiate candidates that truly share your values, and those that share them only as long as it benefits them. A few examples:

https://www.deccanherald.com/international/this-bengaluru-it...

https://qz.com/india/1010965/a-former-executive-is-accusing-...

https://www.ustechworkers.com/lawsuit-intels-indian-managers...

https://medium.com/@satyajit/indians-only-hire-indians-i-did...

When I am weaker than you, I ask you for freedom because that is according to your principles; when I am stronger than you, I take away your freedom because that is according to my principles.


As if Americans don’t sometimes exploit other Americans? Cooperation is good and necessary, designating arbitrary in-groups and out-groups through primal bigotry is not.


Too bad, because that's what other groups do, putting those that don't at a disadvantage. And I should add - you speak as if discrimination against nativists is just a hypothetical. But it is already a fact:

In a survey, a third of liberal professors admitted they'd discriminate against conservatives. "Generally speaking, the more liberal the respondent, the more willingness to discriminate and, paradoxically, the higher the assumption that conservatives do not face a hostile climate in the academy.": https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2012/aug/1/liberal-majo...

The University of California requires job applicants to submit a statement on how they helped advance diversity: https://www.ams.org/journals/notices/201911/rnoti-p1778.pdf


Ummm, you’re the one arguing that in-group out-group divisions are desirable. According to YOUR logic, not mine, discriminating based on political viewpoints is a good thing.


I'm arguing it is advantageous for groups that discriminate, but aren't discriminated against. Good is a moral judgement that doesn't enter the picture.


> Good is a moral judgement that doesn't enter the picture.

Cool, then we agree that it's fine for Apple to hire immigrants. Have a nice day.


Well done, I must say.


It’s illegal to discriminate on the basis of citizenship status. You can decline to sponsor visas, but if an immigrant already has work authorization you cannot refuse to hire them just because they are not a citizen.


It benefits the warm fuzzy feelings nationalists get when they think "one less foreigner"

Note how I sad their feelings- it doesn't benefit even the nationalist, as lower quality products costing more don't benefit anyone.


They could increase their offer and attract more talent? They could make the job more favorable to local talent.

Who does this benefit? American Software Engineers. The United States. Tax Payers?

Or we could depress wages by bringing in outside labor and applying handcuffs (H1-B) which will depress wages further. The company wants all the benefits and efficiencies of being in America without paying into the system


> They could increase their offer and attract more talent? They could make the job more favorable to local talent.

If we already have a good engineer who's part of the team and lives locally, what specifically is the benefit to firing this engineer and replacing them with "local" talent? Why is making the job more favorable to "local talent" advantageous?

> American Software Engineers. The United States. Tax Payers?

Again, as an American software engineer who badly needs qualified engineers on my team - what is the specific benefit to me?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: