Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Indeed. Do you have a point?

That they could've made a dent resistant door out of aluminum.



Not sure exactly what series of aluminum car panels are made from, I highly doubt its 7000 series, probably a 2000 or 5000, maximum Yield strength for T6 temper is in 250-350MPa range. That’s still pretty soft.

Cold rolled full hard 301 stainless has yield strength of 1000 MPa. Tesla claims a 30x ultra hard, no one knows quite what that means yet, so maybe that’s 1500MPa yield strength. So call it 6-8x more dent resistant than aluminum at same thickness.

Tesla is using 3mm thick stainless. I can’t imagine standard car panels are more than 1.5mm thick.

Stiffness grows with square of cross sectional thickness.

So it is plausible Tesla’s panels are 20-30x stiffer than regular door panel.

Maybe that’s where they get their 30X from.

What’s your math say?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: